There are 3 things wrong with this book. First of all, the quality of writing is banal, and disgustingly mushy. Much too much is made of the "inner" feelings of the characters; not enough real attention to the plot.
Secondly, the plot revolves around a completely impossible concept - that there is something for women to eat which will permit them to keep producing babies throughout their lives, into old age. This is apparently sheer ignorance of the biology of womens' reproductive ability (i.e. genetically determined, limited number of egg cells).
Third, the writer seems to think this would be a wonderful thing. Whereas actually it would be a disaster for the family so afflicted, when an aging woman has to take care and raise more and more children. A disaster both physically and financially. And with an aging husband, it would increase by a tremendous amount the chance of producing deformed or handicapped babies. And, since the world's major problem is too many people straining natural resources and increasing pollution of the environment more and more, the ability to produce excessive numbers of children amounts to a major ecological disaster.
This book was extremely well narrated. The story was quite good-- I enjoyed the evolution of Marina, the main character. This is the 2nd Ann Patchett novel I have read-- the first one being Belle Canto. I enjoy her rather ethereal way of writing and it translates well to an audible version.
I was flowing along, listening to the story, the jungle, the "mission". The narration was fine. The set up looked promising... Slow, but promising. Then, well, somebody might have snacked on the mushrooms! This just got silly I tried to stay connected with the story and the author. Searching for the "Wonder", I found not much more than: "Huh"?
I don't regret listening to this. I do wish I had that credit back though.
Addicted to Audible!
This is the second time I have purchased an ann patchett book based on the awesome recommendations and been disappointed. Both this book and BelCanto disappointed me. Perhaps I just dont like her writing style, the plot was beyond ridiculous and her books seem to all just end bluntly without a well crafted ending. The character development was good. I think she is completely overrated. The only thing I liked was the reader which made it bearable!
I don't really know if I liked this book or not. Its overall is higher for me than either the story or the narration deserves because the writing is actually really good.
The premise is odd, and the characters all behave weirdly. Plus- I don't want to give anything away here- the ending is very hurried. Some fairly major things happen which ordinary people would definately have some moral hesitation over, and there's basically zip by way of ethical crisis despite the fact that every emotion throughout the rest of the book is pretty thouroughly canvased. People act out of character too. The whole thing just feels like the author had a word limit she realized she was closing in on in the last chapter and decided to finish in ten pages or less.
Plus, the whole thing was depressing. There is no part of it where there is a real celebration of life or the sense that things will be better or any kind of true happiness. Even the thing that is supposed to be happy is tainted so that it doesn't actually feel like a good thing at all.
The writing is very good though. The author can string words together in very precise ways to evoke specific emotions or to paint a truely vivid scene. If you ignored the story, it would be worth it for the writing.
Narration was too slow, I had to speed up the i-pod. Could've done without all the dream remembrances. Way too long for not much content. I would not recommend this.
The main character is supposed to be a highly intelligent MD/PhD but she seems really unintelligent and uninteresting Patchett's dialogue. Her character doesn't seem to evolve truly. It was a flat experience for me and the characters became sort of parodies and predictable by the end. I'm not sure I've enjoyed an Ann Patchett since Bel Canto.
Carol Deming Casey
Ann Patchett writes lyrically in all of her descriptions, the eloquence in which she uses the written word to bring to life this memersizing story is beyond reproach. This is the first works of Ms. Patchell I have encountered and it has created a hunger in me for more. Absolutely worth the time to drive into this wonderful piece of work.
Disappointing - mis-leading plot descripition from audible / publishing. Slow paced and for a book about trekking to the jungle in search of a wonder cure and missing researcher(s) I expected a james rollins style and paced adventure. Instead it felt like being trapped in the lead characters head as she bemoaned all her past and present choices from the significant to miniscuile. Plot description way - way off base, its not so much about the the jungle, or the cure etc but rather how she feels about every little detail - made for a very boring read and waste of a credit.
With so much good press, I expected this to be a wonderful book. I had enjoyed Bel Canto. But the very premiss on which this book is built is simply ridiculous. Women chewing on bark, hallucinagenic mushrooms, a cure for malaria, eternal fertility? Just preposterous. Hope Davis is a very good reader. Otherwise, I would have given it up.