I really enjoyed this book. Brooks' prose is beautiful, especially her descriptions of "the Island," which Bethia clearly loved. I really enjoyed and was able to understand the use of archaic American English which in my opinion added greatly to the story. Though some critics have complained about the language and the narrator's performance, I found both to be very effective. I'm not an expert on early American language or pronunciation, but it sounded "right" to me. I found myself wishing that I had the ability and language tools to express myself so meticulously and precisely and I wondered how Brooks learned the language of 17th century America.
This is Bethia's story, not Caleb's. Told in 1st person from Bethia's point of view, we never get inside Caleb's head; we see how various happenings affect him, but don't get a feeling for his experience of them. He's totally missing from many parts of the book. The story of how the early European Americans interacted with the native American population and what effects this had on both is a good framework for this book, but the title is misleading.
The author, Geraldine Brooks, beautifully told this unusual and compelling story. Jennifer Ehle's narration expertly created a believable 17th Century woman telling her story. A perfect blend in audio-books.
Would love to hear Jennifer Ehle read Pride and Prejudice in which she portrayed Elizabeth Bennett to Colin Firth's Darcy!!!
No. I repeatedly listened to it in case I had missed something important, but I had not missed anything.
The book is well-written but boring and contrived. I cannot get interested in the characters or the plot.
Many people criticize the narrator, but I cannot find fault with her since the absence of substance is what irks me.
It inspired me never to read another book by Geraldine Brooks. She may be overrated.
This is the only book out of the last 25 that have bored me to tears. Geraldine Brooks writes well about characters that do not interest a reader. The book is slow and reads more like a romance novel than a work of literature.
I love a good murder mystery or any novel where good overcomes evil. Two of my favorite authors are Frank Peretti and Ted Dekker.
This is my 2nd Geraldine Brooks novel. I was not disappointed. She presents a somewhat fair view of the early settlers and their interactions with the natives and with each other. At the very least, she writes books that I love to read and discuss with others. She's a book club favorite.
Brooks always conducts thorough research of her topics in order to present as accurate and rich a picture of the time and place as possible. Caleb's Crossing is no exception. She has selected an interesting and difficult time in the early history of the Massachusetts Bay Colony. Written in the voice of the daughter of a preacher on Martha's Vineyard, she has addressed the issues of religious zealotry, woman's place in that society, inter-class dynamics, and prejudice against Native Americans. She is a truly gifted writer and her characters, although carefully defined by the values and beliefs of the era, are compelling and believable. Like her other books, she manages to connote struggle, tragedy, passion, and redemption. I know some people have an issue with the reader, but Brooks always seems to find the right voice for her stories. I felt Jennifer Ehle was a good choice for this book.
The story captivates you and carries you along right to the end. A thoroughly enjoyable experience.
The relationship between Bethia and Caleb and her immediate acceptance and loyalty to him throughout the story.
The conversations between people are more alive.
Yes. I have a bias in favor of audible editions because of some visual problems, but I would prefer this particular edition in any case.
The characterization was superb. I felt an understanding for the Puritanical father even though I disagreed with so many of his convictions. The other characters were presented also in depth.
The interpretations of each character through her renditions of the voice of each.
I would have enjoyed that, but I looked forward to each time I had opportunity to listen as a special treat.
As my title indicates, the in depth research along with a good fictional adaption provided a great way to gain historical insights.
Yes as I know that friends would love this book like I did.
How hard life must have been and the plain make sense part about growing corn.