I am an Australian woman who enjoys reading many different styles of books, from history to sci fi and mystery to poetry.
Will Wheaton does a terrific job of narrating this wonderful story. I could have done without John Scalzi's input though. An engaging story without being too overly taxing on the old brain matter.
I haven't read the original (yet) so, for me, this was its own story.
I love a book which gets literal LOL moments and this one had a few. Of course having cuddly cat-things didn't hurt, either :)
As per my always, Will Wheaton is a fantastic narrator! Quite humorous to hear him refer to & give voice to a particular character, which I will let you discover yourself.
Ok, so the book was good - and the bonus of being able to listen to the original version of the story was just that, a bonus.
But the main purpose of this review is to warn about the character dialog:
As soon as I started listening to this book I remembered why it had been in my wishlist and not in my library.
This book reminded me of another of Scalzi's efforts: "RedShirts" - in which the dialog between characters may drive you to distraction.
"I do" said A.
"What do you do" asked B.
"I do what I want" said A.
"That's not a proper answer" replied B.
The above may be *readable*, but when narrated all of the "he said, she said" stuff gets very old, very quickly.
In the future I may stick to the print/kindle versions of Scalzi's books.
PS: Wil Wheaton, as usual, does an awesome job narrating.
I was hesitant to get this audio book because I read many negative comments on Amazon, but I like Scazi and Wheaton, so for it anyway, and I am glad I did.
The characters are interesting. The main one is insufferable and likeable at the same time.
I have still to finish the original book, but this one stands on its own.
I bought the audiobook on a whim since i liked Wil Wheaton's performance in Ready Player One. Damn I was not disappointed! He puts on a stellar performance bringing out the various characters. The story itself is very good and even though its only around 8 hours long, it felt longer and by the end of it.. I could say i was extremely satisfied with everything.
p.s the audiobook not only made me laugh, but.. made me cry.. which is kind of scary since the people at work were wondering what happened haha.
I really enjoyed this story from the beginning to the end. Scalzi made some creative changes from the original. In the original Jack Holloway was a simple prospector and Scalzi made him into a more youthful and more enjoyable character with a sense of humor. I enjoyed Carl, Jack's faithful 4 legged friend who enjoys using explosives.
The "Rip off" was like an episode of Law and order. It got me thinking what if a superior beings came to Earth, would they think that we where just simple animals and treat us like we treat animals?
John Scalzi did a great job keeping with traditional story by H. Beam Piper. I was easy to listen and appreciate the original story from 1962. 51 years later John Scalzi brought a great story back from the dead. I would never have had a chance in finding the orginal had it not been for the "Rip off"
Funny, Fast, Engaging.
The story is well written, very funny and enjoyably fast paced. No need in getting bogged down in details, just cut to the next interesting scene.
Nothing in particular, but there are a lot of funny scenes.
The narration is, like every Will Wheaton book, exceptional.
The story takes you to a place where few book dare to go. It's almost as short as a long novella, so you never get bored with the charcacters. Its, About 8 hours long. The last 8 hours is the book which was used to inspired this one.
The narrator is great, and the story is well phased and funny. The court scenes were great and well written, and the dialogues between the different characters is very funny.
At times the story get so funny, you can't stop laughing, but then gets serious and sometimes really really sad.
The end is totally unexpected.
From Selfish to Fuzzy
Engrossing story. Simply stunning performance.
This book draws you in slowly and Wheaton's narration does the same. It isn't showy and it seems very simple and understated at first but this book got me by the first third so bad that it just consumed all the free time I had this weekend! I'm actually glad it wasn't longer!
Jack, the main character, is so lovably caustic.
Yes, but you aren't getting anything else out of me.
If you like sci-fi or courtroom dramas this is likely to be a winner for you. It probably isn't for everyone. Wheaton's narration is solid but understated which is not everyone's preference. His pacing is excellent. He does a great job with the difficult creature voices but he makes no attempt at Jim Dale style theatrics. That said each character, and all dialogue, is easy to follow--no easy feat for Scalzi's fast paced banter.