Erik Larson has set the bar very high for himself. Devil InThe White City and Thunderstruck were wonderful reads as was Isaac's Storm to a lesser extent. In The Garden of Beasts is not very engaging and it's characters are relatively uninteresting. The topic is also very tired.
I would recommend any of his other books over this one. It's really not worth the read.
There was nothing special or engaing about Dodd or his daughter. I had a difficult time keeping up with side stories and characters. Felt as though I needed an org chart.
I loved Devil in the White City and Thunderstruck. They are two of my very favorite books. Here Erik Larson takes three steps backwards and returns to the style of Isaac's Storm, only worse. This entire book can be summed up in one paragraph and save everyone a credit. It is boring. I kept waiting for the point and it never arrived.
This story was well researched and is told with colorful language. VERY interesting account of an American family in pre-war Germany as Hitler took over. Lots of fascinating details about Germany, Hitler, and how the United States (@ home and abroad) viewed Hitler's Germany. The characters were well developed. I had never heard any of these accounts before. Larson sure did his homework. Bravo!
He managed the accents well. Did not over act. Nice pace, easy to understand.
Not extreme, but what I learned from this book is unforgettable.
I am glad my book club chose this to read. Good discussion book.
Very moving. Erik Larsen has a gift for breathing life into history's unsung heroes and lending dimension to it's well-known villains. Beautifully told. I understand there's a film in development. I SO hope it gets made, and made well enough to do the book justice.
Detailed view into a riveting time in history. Larson always delivers.
Narrator: although I am always very impressed with the feat of narrating an audio book, this narration let me down a bit when the German words were not pronounced correctly. I am German, but am not looking for accent-free pronunciation. But the stress and rhythm of the word should be reproduced, so the word is recognizable. I wish the producers would have put more emphasis on coaching these words.
Otherwise a wonderful book - I highly recommend it!
This author took what had to be an exciting time in Germany and reduced it to boredom. I thought that this book might shed some light on every day life during this time, instead it was a book about a ill-suited diplomat who was appointed by a distracted president and his boring time in Berlin. The only intrigue (if you can call it such) was his daughter's lack of morality and insistence on bedding just about everyone she came into contact with. There was no suspense, no great turning point for the family but just a boring account of probably the only boring diplomat in the world. The Night of Long Knives is reduced to a lackadaisical happening. I've heard good things about Larson. I had heard him compared to Hillenbrand; it isn't a fair comparison as he isn't in the same league. I hope this isn't his best work but based on this I won't be reading anything else written by Larson.
I enjoy listening to books much more than reading. My favorite genres would be sci fi, history and fiction.
If they were wanting a historical viewpoint on Germany prior to WWII then yes.
Overall this book was more like listening to a lecture than a story.
It is already a movie which I haven't seen.
Yes, I would recommend this book, as a true story with Hitler and the horror of Nazi Germany is usually often stranger than fiction. This book has all the characters, time frame, and an unusual American Ambassador and his family to be amazing. I was just disappointed that it was told so lecture style. I felt the drama of the situations were not told well. Accurate but too much like an essay.
Yes, and I have read "Devil In The White City" which I thought was better.
Very good. He can pronounce German very well. But this story gave him little opportunity to create voices for his characters.
OH YES! A movie will give the characters more life.This should make a fantastic movie. The love story, the fear of Hitler and his diabolical plans, and the political intrigues sounds perfect for a good film-maker.
First, I would have that book read by someone who has at least basic knowledge of proper German pronunciation.
Is it too much to ask, to have a book brimming with German terms and names performed by someone who does not mangle each and every German word?
Asides from those audible (sic!) issues, I could not really warm to any of the leading figures. Dodd seems to have been a misfit extraordinaire for the post of ambassador. He just couldn't rise above being a self-righteous, slightly desiccated dusty old professor, who felt intellectually superior to basically everybody.
The petty squabbles with the embassy staff just proved to me that the man was not a leader but just an annoying failure as a diplomat, couldn't even motivate his own people.
A true diplomat would have been much better suited to the position and by possibly seeing the bigger picture, a better choice for that important post might have effected changes instead of handing out affronts.
All characters remain somewhat abstract and two-dimensional. The slutty daughter did not garner any sympathies from me either, and her having been a spy for the Soviets, was downplayed like an afterthought. I found the mere fact scandalous.
In general, I felt like I wasted my time with that book.