Steinbach's characters' come to life as you listen to their troubling lives,and
feel their frustrations... as their hopes, dreary lives, and personalities weave
their story in the Great Depression.
What can I say about Steinbeck? Such a great writer - its so amazing that this all happened in America, CA, and specifically in the Monterey area where I also live. What a sad history lesson. Steinbeck was, and is, a bigger than life figure in our area - so reconnecting with his writing was great. I agree with a previous review, the harmonica interludes were annoying and need to be remixed so they aren't so loud. Only complaint.
I have read the book and seen the movie. The audio edition is in a whole different category.
When the fight was prevented at the government camp.
The inflection in his voice and his pronunciation of the colloquialisms.
When I was told that High School students are forced to read this book I was astonished. This book is like olives. As an adult, with a mature palate, you can appreciate the potency and complexity of an olive. But give it to a kid and they will spew it out of their mouth! There is so much to think about in this story. If you read this in High School, read it again as I think you will find a whole new world of meaning.
It can seem plodding at times. My high school son thought he took too many tangents, I found the tangents the most interesting. This book takes time, and it is not a happy story. Especially, if you see how relevant it is to us today.
Its way up there
A Fine Balance by Rohinton Mistry
it was excellent. His portrayal of the car salesman part was great.
There are soooo many books yet to 'read' so I probably wouldn't...but I would highly recommend this to others.
Ma. She had the biggest character transformation from meek wife to leader of the family.
Yes...but it was entirely too long for that! I ended up changing the speed to fast on my MP3 player so that I could get to the next 'thing' quicker. The narrator was good but a bit slow for my preference.
Trans- formative experience
The reality of this story and performance make you feel like you are witnessing the events. Excellent historic fiction.
Liked them all - masterful performance by author
My reaction was a pity to see further evidences of life without A relation with Jesus Christ - not religion but relationship.
I've now put East of Eaden on my wish list!
I hadn't appreciated this book much in high school. From a more experienced perspective I now see what a fantastic book it is. It raises questions about human existence that are both timeless and timely. Paradoxically, Americans are far better off now than in the era portrayed in the book, and yet in many regards events and attitudes seem entirely too familiar. If you wonder whether there can be a compelling alternative to the recent ascendance of Objectivism, look no further.
While Baker's vocal take on Tom Joad became rather grating after a while, the variety and consistency with which the characters are voiced makes them all the more memorable and three-dimensional. I've never heard a male performer do such a great job with female voices.
yes it helped me stay focused into the story
Tom or Al Joad, Because I can relate to them the best
The head of the Womens Committee
You need to have some more excitement in the voices sometimes.... I know its a sad book but most of the book is monotone.....
It seems most readers nowadays approach this book because of a course in American Literature and, in the true essence of college students everywhere, grab a video of the movie and a copy of Cliff's Notes and leave it at that.
They are missing a great tale of a great migration. This is a story akin to the Pilgrims crossing the Atlantic or the Pioneers in their wagon trains; the second wave of the poor who fled their homes and lands with the hope they could begin anew and, this time, succeed. These are the people who fled the pogroms, the potato famines, the wars and came with hands itching to work in the new world.
The land they left was the mid west and they fled the Depression, the Dust, and their Debt. GRAPES OF WRATH is a tale of the American Clearances, as dreadful and any clearance of the Highlands, and the struggle to survive the savages: the California landowners and their unofficial armies who feared the influx of this mass of people, the California politicians who feared loss of their seats of power, the California people who feared their need to help them, to take care of them. "Okies," we called them to make them a different animal and not a fellow human being.
To better understand their plight, stop halfway through and listen to THE WORST HARD TIMES by Timothy Egan. Then come back and finish this book.
Like the words of the Grateful Dead song Touch of Gray ... I will get by ... I will survive.