Mick is my favorite MC character. 5th Witness was not as good as the previous 2 Mickey books but still a great listen. It gets an extra star due to the great performance by Peter Giles. Giles once again does an excellent job bringing Mick to life. How anyone think Giles doesnt do a great job with Mickey is beyond me.
As a recovering lawyer myself, I rarely read legal thrillers -- I wonder, do doctors avoid medical thrillers for the same reason? But, having liked the early Harry Bosch books, I decided to give this Michael Connolly book a chance. Bottom line: unless I find some other Haller book on a really good sale somewhere, I probably won't buy any more. It's primarily ear fodder, nothing more.
First the good: it's fun to see Connolly insert real people into the novel -- Hollywood agent supreme Joel Gotler, Shami Arselanian, the forensics expert. Rather cleverly done, I thought. Then too, Connolly did a great job of describing the client from hell. I suspect every lawyer has had one of more of these nightmares come in for help and representation. Suffice it to say that Connolly described "Lisa" so perfectly it made the hair on the back of my neck stand up. Horrors. Been there, done that. (The client from hell is one who doesn't tell you everything, but holds some stuff back, especially the really damaging stuff. They they go off on their own, talking to the media, contacting people, trying to "help". Can drive you nuts -- not to mention kill their own case.) Connolly did that very well.
Now the bad: it's nothing short of mind-numbing to listen to page after page of trial transcript. "And what did you do with the piece of paper then?" "I put it into an envelope." "And what did you do with the envelope?" I put it into the evidence locker..." On and on and on, trivia, to the point that you consider a primal scream as the only possible remedy. If you're reading the book, you can skim and skip all this nonsense. If you're listening, you're pretty much stuck.
But worse than that, I think, is Connolly's -- or "Michael Hallers" -- endless pontificating about what he does in front of the jury, and why he does it. We listen to how -- and exactly where -- he places his hands on his hips, the expression he assumes on his face, how he spins and turns and walks away, all the while wondering if the jury is getting his message. Yes. I expect everyone in the Western world now realizes that a trial is nothing but showtime, and the lawyers must be actors more than anything else -- no wonder Connolly and Joel Gotler are such good friends. But still, Connolly carries it to the point of absurdity. He makes Haller look like a fool, in my opinion. In my experience, most juries -- all except the OJ one, anyway -- would see right through poor acting like this, and penalize the lawyer who does it. From Connolly's description, there's not a shred of sincerity anywhere in Haller's makeup. I don't think that plays well -- with juries not to mention with any of Haller's former wives.
So-so: I thought the plot device of having the prosecution drop "new evidence" on the defense --over and over again, ad nauseum -- both just before and during the trial got a little silly. Too much. And Haller's outrage each time was identical to the time before. I got tired of it.
Summary? I now live in Israel where we don't have jury trials. Judges make decisions on court cases, not lay juries. After reading one of the Michael Haller books, I have more reason than ever before before to thank Gd for that aspect of our national system of justice.
The story line, the suspense and the narrator made the story really great. Peter Giles voice just seemed to fit the Mickey Haller I had in my mind.
I really liked the fact that with Michael Connelly's books, you don't anticipate who the bad guy is, or even sometimes know where the story is going all together. The story line is not preditctable.
His narration brings life each character. He doesn't over do it with his voice when it comes to the female characters and make them seem unreal, like I've heard with some narrators.
This is just simply the best. I read this right after I read Lincoln lawyer. This scores better then lincoln lawyer. I like the trial episodes which was done very well. The performance of the narrator was very impressive and adds a zest to the book reading. Overall, very satisfying experience with this book. Couldn't wait to get another Mikki Haller series.
Another winner by Mr. Connelly! Mickey is a fun character but it was also nerve-wracking! Great narration also by Mr. Giles!
I awarded this one five stars, although I rarely rate anything that highly. And before I gush, I have to say that audio versions show up Michael Connelly's writing style for what it is: a pedestrian, "just the facts, Ma'am" deadpan that is quicker to read than to listen to. However, this one kept me awake and listening because Connelly keeps the plot propelling along nicely. The narrator, Peter Giles, is pitch perfect as Mickey Haller. If you have followed his adventures in previous books, you know Mickey, his ex-wives, his daughter, and the rest of his entourage. That story line continues in the context of a new legal thriller that revolves around the foreclosure debacle. Connolly oversimplifies that situation, but, after all this is a page-turner pop novel, not an article in The Economist:) And Connelly plays fair, providing sufficient info to figure things out. Highly entertaining, with a boffo ending that sets things up for the next in the series. Go, Mickey!
I would love to hear his next book read by someone whose delivery is more nuanced. This reader punches out every sentence using the same dramatic cadence. As much as I was riveted by the plot, the narration was an annoying distraction. Having just seen The Lincoln Lawyer, I would love to hear Mickey Haller portrayed by someone with real acting skills. Will Patton, perhaps?
I am an avid eclectic reader.
This is Michael Connelly at his best. Peter Giles did a great job with the narration. I could hardly stop listening even went to bed with the IPOD and next thing I know it was morning! Then ending was a surprise and a good set up for his next book. Connelly managed to wind Micky's introspection with his values and problems with his x-wife in and around the main story without making the story lag or get you sidetracked.