I have always loved to read, and now I really enjoy listening to my books as well!!
I am very glad I listened to this true story. I learned quite a bit about the Afghan culture that I never really understood before. This is not a depressing story, however. It does not contain unbearable violence as other books with a similar subject have. It is uplifting, and a very rewarding listen.
The story is really quite heroic considering the limitations of citizens, especially women, under the Taliban rule. We can not really understand the enormity of everything Kamila accomplished because we cannot imagine living in such horrible times. She is clearly an amazing woman.
The book is well written, and the narrator is excellent. I highly recommend to anyone who is considering the purchase--
One of the best audio books I've listened to. I couldn't wait to get back in the car!
mom of six
Different author. I kept thinking that I should have felt some kind of emotional connection to this story, but I never did. It's a shame. The actual story about Camila has so much potential with the right author. There were a lot of holes in the story--pieces that I was surprised the author had just left out.
Three Cups of Tea. Both good stories with bad authors. Three Cups of Tea ended up being full of falsehoods. This one has been accused of the same thing.
Have a book club discussion about the book.
Emotionally devoid. Shame on this journalist for not being able to produce a better book.
Inaccurate details about Afghanistan , Would have helped if the author had really gone to that country and spent some time learning the culture and the language. The narration was even worse.
The author needs to stick to stories about what she knows and leave it to the likes of Khaled Hosseini to write about Afghanistan.
I guess I was expecting something on the order of "The Kite Runner." Didn't realize it was not a novel. Still, once I realized it was a true story it didn't quite come up to "Three Cups of Tea" in its ability to capture my attention. I enjoyed it, I was not bored, but somehow it was not powerful enough a narrative to push me over the "3 Star" mark
This is a good book, with a surprising gentleness for the topic, as the author presents it with the perspective of the real life subjects. As an American, I was initially frustrated not to read descriptions of terror, anger, and strong responses on the part of the subjects, but I am thinking that the tone of this book, more than many others, may truly present the perspective of these deeply religious women who live in a culture with responses to the terror around them that are very different than our own. The family's innermost emotions are not conveyed here; we don't witness that, (the author very carefully avoids any personal analysis; it could have been written by the women themselves, who carefully preserve their privacy as an aspect of their culture) but we do get to see how they respond outwardly, which is with strength, determination, and a constant deep respect for each other with in the world that they live. These women LIVE by their faith in everything that they do in a way that many of us would have difficulty comprehending in our secular societies. I learned more about this very different culture than about the Taliban, which was fine with me.
This was a wonderful book that helped me learn about another part of the world that helped me to understand the culture better. What a brave young woman!!
I loved how the story moved along, kinda kept me on the edge of my seat.
How it showed the strength and cunning of these women.
It was a story I wanted to stretch out longer.
I recommend to all my friends. It's a beatiful story everyone must know.
The interpretation was great.