I was really disappointed in this audio book. The first series was so well done, both the writing and the narrator, I just expected this book to be of the same caliber. But it wasn't.
I haven't finished it yet. I don't know if I will. I am over half-way but so far, I haven't cared about what happens to any of the characters.
After listening to Steven Pacey who was such an awesome narrator for the first series, I really found it difficult to listen to Michael Page. He is not up to the quality of Steven Pacey. His long passages were monotonous and lost me on several occasions. Although he did have different voices for each character, they were not as colorful, nor as easily recognized as Steven Pacey's characters. Overall, the book is a disappointing waste of time.
Stop jumping around in the POV and give me someone to care about. Go back to using Steven Pacey as the narrator.
I have purchased another of Joe Abercrombie's books with Michael Page as the narrator so I will give it a try. However, if I had not already made the purchase, I would not buy the book based on the fact that Michael Page is the narrator.
only if they change the narrator.
I'm assuming that if you're thinking of reading this book, that you've read the series from the very beginning. As a stand alone book, I think most would find this annoying without the background information on the characters.
As I have followed the series since the beginning, I was already intimate with the strengths and weaknesses of the characters in the series, and I am familiar with the dark style of story telling that is Joe Abercombie. As a result, these issues were not a distraction for me.
Standing on it's own merits, I found the story to be well crafted and very enjoyable. Once I started it, I found it hard to stop listening and couldn't wait to get back to it once I had. This is a hallmark o a very enjoyable work.
As for the narration: I think Michael Page is a first rate narrator in his own right , but he has a very difficult task of trying to continue behind another master. Switching narrators in a series is never a good idea, as listeners are always shaped and then biased to the narrator that introduced them to the series. That is the case here, although once you get over this, the performance is very good.
So, if you have liked the series to date, you will likely find this book as good!
Do you like the "Flashman" books by George Macdonald Fraser? The "Sharpe" books by Bernard Cornwell? The unflinching portrayal of combat and war in movies such as "Platoon"? Then this book is for you.
The absurdities of the functioning of large armies. The politics of conflict. The personal pettiness that affect both. I found myself laughing out loud many times at the internal monologues of hard-done-by Bremer dan Gorst, hard-bitten Corporal Tunney, and war-weary Curndon Craw.
Joe Abercrombie's dry/black humour is masterfully narrated by Michael Page as he captures the voice and sentiment of each point-of-view character.
Why are you still reading? Go get this book and start listening!
While the story isn't up-to-par with "The First Law" series, it's entertaining enough... But once again, Michael Page's narration, penchant for giving virtually every character an undue amount of gravitas and O-V-E-R E-N-U-N-C-I-A-T-I-O-N basically ruins it.
For the hell of it, I listened to the first 30 minutes of "The Blade Itself" and I nearly cried with joy and sadness at not having Steven Pacey read the books that follow.
I can only hope and pray that Mr. Pacey is brought back when and if Mr. Abercrobie returns us to our old friends Sand dan Glokta, the unwitting Jezal dan Luthar and the ever-so-practical Logen Ninefingers.
I didn't care for it after the feel of the characters changed so much. It it s bit of a disappointment from the reader.
love audio books - Anglophile
I still miss Steven Pacey's narration. His reading of the First Law trilogy was pure magic. Luckily I have the book of The Heroes, so I'm just going to read it.
I read the reviews. I even wrote a review myself for Best Served Cold also narrated by Michael Page. I didn't listen to myself, and I didn't listen to the folks who posted their reviews for Heroes. I should have listened! The narration is terrible; even worse than Best Served Cold. It destroys what would otherwise be a terrific story.
I am usually a pretty persistent individual and can cope with poor narration to at least get through the novel, but not this time. I've had to stop listening and I'll buy the book instead. What a shame because Steven Pacey did such a brilliant job of The First Law series.
I don't know what all the grumbling is about ... I thought the narrator did a great job. It's been over a year since I listened to the other books in this series, so perhaps that's why I didn't notice a narration change.
But seriously ... Michael Page does a fine job, and his rendition of Gorst is fantastic. He also did a great job with Best Served Cold. Don't let the 'new' narrator keep you from listening to this book - you won't be dissappointed with his storytelling.