I think it was an excellent story. It started a bit slow though, but it gradually picked up. It did take a bit to get used the accent of the narrator, but it still was a nice listen.
When Jane gets decapitated in order to remove the Scarab. And when Dryfuss meets the Clockmaker.
I'm going to have to say Gafney. He made me see his sneers without ever seeing him. Second is Sparva.
I only have a handful of Sci-Fi to rank it with and I would put this at about the mid point... if I could ignore the narration, I could give it better marks.
The narration was the sticking point for me on this audiobook. Lee gives very little life to most of the characters and his accent lends itself to about two-three variations. His pauses between between words became predictable and were kept between characters. It really became annoying.
Annoyance at times... but again, due to the narration. Not sure why people enjoy Lee so much. But I have not heard any of his other work... maybe it is just me.
The Prefect is a great sci-fi story. The tech is really inventive. The plot is unique. Some of the character interaction is a little bit unbelievable and at times brings what should be a climatic pace down to a crawl. I attribute this partly to the narration.
But which Prefect?
Maybe Dune, due to the Plans within Plans aspect of the plot. However, it's been a very long time since I read that so the comparison is probably imperfect.
The conversation with the Clockmaker.
Nothing's as simple as it seems.
For followers of the Revelation Space series, this book gives some cultural background on the Glitter Band and the Demarchists in general.
What can I say. Great story, great characters, great writer.What more could you want?Thanks Alastair. Your writing has hooked my 12 year old on sci fi. Nurds rule!
Elder Statesman Doctor
Only somewhat. There were a lot of good parts but there was also some significant weakness in some of the structure. Specifically there were multiple times when things went wrong for the 'good guys' in unrealistic ways. For example, a doctor going in to see a dangerous criminal patient with no guards to back him up, or when people are taken hostage by someone, but apparently the entire police authority does not have any automatic processes that would notice or detect this is happening in a much more technologically advanced society than ours. Or the lack of ability in a police operating theater for a surgeon to just speak up and immediately request security to rush to where he is for protection or to apprehend the criminal!
Multiple moments of anxiety and suspense.
Excellent voice control, captures differences in voice for different characters well.
Audible screwed up the placement of this as part of a series. They have it listed as #5 in the series. It SHOULD BE # 1, or listed as a prequel, as all the action in this occurs Before the action in Volumes 1 through 4 !
I have enjoyed all but one of Alastair Reynolds' books (Absolution Gap being the one exception). If you have liked any of his other books, you will enjoy this one, too. You almost always feel you're there in his stories, this is no exception -- you imagine you are on this not so alien world, along for the adventure.
John Lee does an excellent job, as always. One of my favorite narrators.
The concept of this book was great. The narrator was good as well.
I found the characters a bit simple ...... The lead character was overly right all the time ... it got a bit annoying ..... The ending was abrupt that left me asking myself what just happened..... it ended so quickly ...
Even with my negative comments i did enjoy the book .. I guess I enjoyed it enough that I wanted it to be just that much better
I found a lot of the solutions to THE PROBLEM they were dealing with had much better and obvious solutions than the courses of action they took. It took a little ignoring of dumb stuff. But, on the whole it was pretty good.
Yes. Just listening to some of the dialogues spoken make WAY more impact than if you just read them.
Clepsydra - she is an enigmatic person. Very much like the Oracle from the Matrix movies, but with an action element.
He had a good voice, and different characters were well portrayed in different voices.
No. This is a book, I wanted to take some breaks with. This novel does have horror elements to it, but very subtly portrayed. It was exhaustingly detailed - but well put together.
This novel has a lot of harsh events, which are subtly mentioned in passing. 2, 3 or a few one can stomach. But, almost all scenes have people dying or talk of people dying or dead people in them! I didn't notice until half way through the novel, why I was feeling sick in the stomach listening to this novel. In the end, I figured out it was all the bleak events - kids dying, people being experimented upon, innocent people being starved, innocent victims, killing of people in who've suffered enough already, mass murder, mass destruction, mass murderers going on loose and collateral damage. AND, this is just the tip of it!
Be warned if you are someone who gets affected by the novels you are listening to. The only positive is that all these horrors are well blended, and not graphic. So, it's not easy to pick it out.
John Lee continues to do an excellent job in his performance of the audio book. I'd rate the story about 3.5 stars. It's better than most and people interested in hard sci-fi should take a look at this story. That said, the ending is very unsatisfying and on the way, the author has far too many plot threads and it seemed to be unnecessarily complex, but my main complaint is the ending which is basically a deus ex machina.