Yes, the story is fun and I liked the mystery, even if the writing wasn't particularly good.
A bit like Twilight for the scholarly type. The comparison is a bit unfair bc in general I think this book is better written than Twilight, but it does share the whole vampire-stud motif (although Matthew is a much more complex and real character than Edward Cullen).
Matthew, just to hear his life story
Any Oxford student, tutor, or alumni would cringe at how Harkness likes to just drop in place names for no apparent reason. And the narrator, Ikeda, mispronounces Magdalen (the first clue for an Oxford outsider). Although as a former member of New College, I did like that my college was showcased so prominently.
A Discovery of Witches contains the outline of an interesting story but desperately needs a ruthless editor. The plot has definite potential. I found Elias Ashmole and the manuscript Ashmole 782 really interesting and I loved the house where Diana's Aunt Sarah lived. However, in the end A Discovery of Witches becomes quite simply a romance (and not even a very good one). It is repetitive, at times boring, frequently annoying and full of cliches. And yet ... I kept listening (the narrator is very good). I hoped it would get better. It never did. I'm almost embarrassed to admit I felt compelled to read the next book. I think I gave Harkness a second chance because I was still interested in the world that she was trying to create. Unfortunately, the second in this trilogy (Shadow of Night) was also a book of lost potential. I won't be trying the third.
Intelligent writing, thoroughly researched yet keeping a constant pace through the story.
Perhaps some of the Diana Gabaldon books may come close.
I loved the scenes in the Bodleian, so much tension amongst those dusty tomes in the sphere of academe!
Matthew for sure. He'd be educational and sexy at the same time, what a combination!
This is a class act and it was a pleasure to hear it read by a reader with such a gift for appreciating the prose.
Avid audio book listener who has recently become a Kindle addict!!
It wasn't just about vampiral sexual exploits which made a nice difference.
Most of it was good although I liked it when Dianna fell into Mathews arms at the library for the first time.
This is one of the best audio books I've listened to. Second only to the True Blood series for content and performance by the narrator.
I enjoyed the premise of the story - a story about a historian and witch who doesn't want to use her (immense) powers meets enigmatic vampire and sets about changing supernatural laws whilst trying to discover the whereabouts of an important manuscript that could change all of their lives forever.
Characters are interesting - storyline is intruiging and even though it can be a little predicable in places, it's unusual enough the rest of the time to keep your interest.
Best part about this story so far though is the awesome narration. The narrator is an amazing actor and does flawless accents (including English and French!) which really adds depth and flavour to the book.
Really, really enjoyable to listen to! I recommend this book and am looking forward to listening to the sequel.
My favourite character so far is, strangely, Isabeau. Small part (as yet) but I just loved the accented characterisation.
The most memorable character for me is definitely the protagonist, Diana. As the story develops and she discovers more and more about her powers, she becomes more interesting. She's feisty, independent, very intelligent and a very powerful witch. In a supernatural story, it doesn't get much better.
Love the book and looking forward to the next installment. Read it. It's lots of fun!
Hot romance/Sci Fi we're so lucky to have Audible to feed our book addictions. I love walking my precious dog Sydney & listening to my books
This was a very enjoyable and gripping listen. The story is captivating and keeps you in it's grips. The characters are addictive and added perfectly. The narrator does an excellent job with her soothing smooth voice and portrays all characters very well. I am of to read the next in this stimulating series. Thanks Deborah, a fabulous job all round :)
I quite enjoyed this book, but I really wish I'd known it only begins the story! The character development was well done with the exception of Matthew, who I found a little too unrealistic, but it was fun nonetheless because let's face it, us girls love a ridiculously unrealistic romantic lead - romance *is* escapism after all ;) I'm assuming this is part of a series, although it isn't listed as such. Frustrating - I love wading through long series, but I prefer to know before I begin. Sort of spoiled an otherwise enjoyable listen, so I figured I'd review this to let people know (without spoilers) that this is just part one of a story. If this is all there is, I must say I'll be deeply disappointed.
I just couldn't stop reading this book. It is such a combination of a love story & history that I found it very intriguing. Add in the supernatural and you really have a winner. I really hope that there is going to be a follow up novel because I would really like this story to continue. Loved the combination of Diana & Matthew.
I could only sit through a little bit
a different person
I didnt listen to all of it so I couldnt choose