George Guidall is a good reader, but does not always bring the voices to life. I will never attempt to read another Jonathan Franzen book.
It has turned me off from this author.
He speaks clearly and steadily.
These people are pathetic and their pitiful mind machinations just made me tired. Even jumping ahead when the though garbage bogged me down did not save it for me.
I have nothing to offer anyone except my own confusion.
Yes, as its' one of the single greatest novels ever written. The story captivates from beginning to end, brings a variety of timely social issues to the table and tells a great story around the discussion of those issues.
Chip's arrival at the home for Christmas, which seemed predictable but at the same time the author gave no clue that it would actually happen ... or Alfred's dementia induced talking feces..
His voice actually bothered me at first, or at least for the first few minutes of the listen. As you get involved with the characters of the novel what at first listen seems like the voice of an elderly man becomes capable of giving each character a completely distinct voice, and ultimately ends up in a great listening experience.
Neither, but there were numerous moments when Gary and Chip were placed into situations I, like many men, had experienced in real life.
I kept listening and it threw off my sleepiing pattern. I could not fall asleep to the book as I kept wondering what would happen next.I do not know if it was te story or the narrator that gripped my attention. I highly enjoyed it despite losing sleep.
I have already listened to Freedom and really enjoyed it, and I would listen to another based on Freedom. But this just didn't strike me.... I always finish a book (except Life of Pi, but that had to do with not wanting to listen to the death of the tiger) no matter how much I dislike it, and this is one I couldn't wait for it to be over!
The way the story was put together. All the pieces were there, but it just didn't grab me.
Yes, George was just fine.
All the characters were appropriate, the story just wasn't interesting to me.
Avid reader of classics and fiction, history and well-written genre novels. Music lover and huge audiobook fan.
Read this for a second time after passage of a decade. Hadn't remembered how depressing the story was, and how frustrating the characters, but was stunned by how very deeply down the book made me feel without allowing me to separate from it. I had to keep reading. The prose is beautiful and continues to draw you in for even the saddest and most absurd developments. There is a line in this book that i love about how can one even stand when you don't understand how difficult another's life can be. It is such an amazing and critical line that it stays after with me long after I have finished the book. THat is why I read. I want to imagine how difficult it is to live someone else's life because that understanding makes life easier to live for me. I found this an amazingly honest and compassionate book despite how very uncompassionate it starts out.The reader is excellent although the woman's characters got sort of high-pitched voices that can be really irritating.Excellent narrator and interpretation. Highly recommended
This ranks in the middle 50%. I went on forever with drawn out sub plots. I identified with the main character and that made it painful. I'll try another Franzen book and see f I can get through it without getting frustrated.
That George Guidall was the reader.
You know, that's a hard one for me to answer. EVERYTHING that George Guidall reads comes to life. It's quite amazing. The way that he can truly separate one character from another; the way that he does wormen just makes him the very best in this art form..I have reached a point in my audio book listening experience that has me looking for books that he has read, no matter that I have no idea about the author or plot. I felt the same way about Muller and sorry that he has passed and there will be no more.
Al's infirmity got to me. I'm his age.
Keep 'em coming.
Franzen's ability to get deep inside the heads of his characters and reveal their thoughts, emotions, and motivations is fascinating. Some characters are likeable. Others are not. But they are a very human mix of fear, frailty, hope and desire.
Repetitive and very, very slow moving.
The book could be 1/3 shorter and nothing would be lost in the story.
Brilliant. I bought the book strictly because George Guidall is the narrator. He is my favorite narrator, and I've listen to well over 100 audiobooks. He has a great voice, does exceptionally well with foreign names and place, has a lot of variation in his voice which distinguishes the charactors well (and the voice for each character is appropriate.) His pace is also very, very good.
I can't tell you how many times I laughed out loud while listenting to this book. It is so well written, and so well read! I would listen while on the treadmill and get totally absorbed.
I don't know that this book is similar to any other I've read or listened to. The writing is somewhat similar to Franzen's "Freedom." Franzen is a true word smith!
Not possible to choose!
No -- it has to be savored. The writing is wonderful, but dense.
Get it. Take your time. Enjoy!!