I was very disappointed in both the narration (too dramatic) and the book. Kay is now angry, self analyzing and melodramatic. I've read all the Kay Scarpetta books, and didn't like this book at all.
While the story line is a continuation of the previous plots, it really added nothing to character development. The reader was also inconsistent; overly dramatic at times and too bland at others.
Overall this book had a decent "plot" but as with many recent novels by Cornwell this one lacked the ability to finish what it started. Within 10 minutes you go from the beginning of the "tip" point to credits. Everything wrapped up with no real conclusion. Very disappointing.
I've read all of Patricia Cornwell's books and been a fan of Kay Scarpetta for years. But this - between the narrator's unyielding whispery monotone (like nails on a chalkboard) to Kay seemingly losing her backbone while allowing all of her "loved" ones to treat her like the senile great aunt who came to dinner....A hugely disappointing purchase and sad to see/hear a favorite character turn into a neurotic, hyper paranoid, one-dimensional shadow of her former self. Utterly depressing storyline and thoroughly unlikable characters.
I used to love Patricia Cornwell. But the last few books have gotten worse and worse - her main character, Scarpetta,needs to be in Benton's hospital! She has too many issues to be believable in the role she "plays". and there's WAY to much digression and rabbit trails. I've read or listened to all her books up to now - don't think I'll be getting any more.
Finally, Cornwell got us back to the magic of the beginning of the series where the science and the characters were the center ... not weird, unbelievable plots. I did occasionally struggle with hearing the change in voices, but overall a really true-to-the-written-word naration.
An avid reader, demanding of the story, characters and narrator. Mysteries and historical fiction are my favorites.
I was a huge Patricia Cornwell fan during the early years. But something happened. I keep hoping the next book will be better.
This book had dozens of the most frustrating conversations I have ever listened to.
K: "What happened?" B: "What do you think happened?"
K: "Are you saying that Fielding was involved?" B: "You've been gone for a long time, Kay."
To be fair, Cornwell addresses these problems in the narrative, but it was painful to read. And the whole thing seems like a prologue, no a book. I felt cheated.
This was one of those times. I was two-thirds of the way through and I just did not see the point of going on. I was no longer interested. The main thing wrong was the main character - Scarpetta. Cromwell has turned her into one of the most self-centered egotistical paranoids I have ever seen. The story is lost as the mental ramblings of Scarpetta as she goes on and on about how this person slighted her, lied to her, or is out to get her. Even her closest family and friends (Benton, Lucy, and Marino) are lying or undercutting her. It just kept going on and on. It was just too painful to listen anymore. Usually, even with a bad book, after I have this much time invested in the story, I want to see it through to see the resolution. But in this case, there was not even a significant story to keep my interest,
The narrator was OK. I actually began to feel sorry for her.
Yes, I did, I skipped the first half of the book! I started listening on my MP3 player and accidentally selected Part 2 instead of Part 1, and you know what - I never noticed!!! I never caught on that I had started in the middle, until the last hour, when things started wrapping up, and I began to wonder what was going to happen in "Part 2"!
I tried to go back and listen to the first part, but since I already know the end, I couldn't get into it.
I am a Scarpetta fan, but this wasn't really all that thrilling - seemed more about moving the characters along.
Devoted audible mystery user. Been using since 2001 - that's a bunch of books. I've enjoyed every one I purchased through my membership.
I am a great fan of the Scarpetta series, but this one left me wondering about the future of one of my favorite characters. The plot here was great, but the character development that has Scarpetta paranoid toward motives of those closest to her, and depressed about her life is very unlike the courageous and confident woman we have become so familiar with. She is portrayed as exhausted and suspicious of everyone. The end relaxed a bit as things came together, but still leaves questions about how Dr. Scarpetta will survive in the future. I hope the next chapeter is one of redemption. Let's get back to solving mysteries instead of getting mired in the lives of so many people at one time.