Grover Gardner does an excellent job of narration, but that can't overcome a book that is not only very disjointed, but delves way to deeply into topics that should be covered in a few minutes. The book should be retitled "The Ramblings of an Unorganized Mind." Doesn't come close to living up to the hype it received.
Really enjoyed the stories and the reader does a great job, feels like you're actually listening to Mark Twain. There a couple of drawbacks such as the verbiage describing the project that is responsible for the book and the frequent retelling of the difficulties he had with coming up with the format of the autobiography.
I'm a recovering librarian. Since I had a stroke in 2002 I have found reading print difficult. I am so grateful for audiobooks.
The editors??? long and tedious explanation of the autobiographical material takes up most of the first part of this three-part audiobook. I believe that Mark Twain would have had a good laugh at the pomposity of the editors and their footnotes; unfortunately I found it insufferably boring and a very poor use of audio. If I had been reading a print version I would have skimmed or skipped this beginning all together.
I wanted to read Twain???s writing not what all those other folks think I should get out of reading it. A very brief "We got this stuff from lots of different places and times and some of it's literal and some of it isn't. Enjoy," would have been fine with me. Twain does an excellent job of explaining himself.
I enjoyed this book immensely and at times I felt as though I was actually listening to Mark Twain himself. Although this audio book is long, it is well worth taking the time to listen and learn about one of the greatest authors, his demeanor, disposition, strengths and weakness, and finally what made him so great.
Mark Twain's autobiography, right? You'd think Mark Twain wrote it, right? Well, apparently he never wrote an autobiography! This guy,Grover Gardner, with some other Twain fans, put together a collection of bits written by the author on the premise that everything he wrote was autobiographical. They say he "wrote" his autobiography, but did not tell it in a chronological fashion, you just have to guess how old he was and where he was at the time he wrote/lived this stuff. Give me a break. Mark Twain is old news. He was bigoted, conceited and not very nice. In this day and age, I don't think any of his stuff is literature. He made me angry when he wrote about the Hawaiian people in "Mark Twain in Hawaii", and I only bought this book to see if he had more bad things to say about the native people and their royalty. This complete and authoritative edition is just as full of BS as Mark Twain was.
I'm afraid I must agree with all of the negative reviews. I am not a Twain scholar, I am a Twain fan. He is one of America's greatest storytellers. It's a shame that we aren't able to simply enjoy him telling this one last story, the one about himself, without endless footnotes and editorial details.
I'm half way though the 1st volume and I'm afraid I'm going to give up. You'd have to be a huge fan to make it though the hours...and hours of this audiobook. I wish I could "gift" this to someone who might enjoy it.
Sorry this audio book was not very good. If i could get my credit back I would be very happy.
This is unutterably boring, and there's so much of it! It's not just the hours of editorial commentary, but Clemens himself. OMG. Save your money. Reread Huck Finn. You have to give a review at least one star, which explains how it got that.
I was expecting an historical autobiography but was rants and ravings about how important and impressive Mark Twain thought he was! I hung in there for 4+ hours but had to give it up. Reader was good, story line sucked.