Best: the description of the birth of the Atlantic and the history of it's exploration. Excellent explanations and recounting of a lot of history in an understandable, succinct way. Loved the historical anecdotes. Although it was hard to hear, there was an important message about mankind's abuse of the ocean and it's sea life.
Least: the overall structure of the book. It was, at points, an obvious stretch to make the content fit the structure. Instead of the structure helping to lay out so much information in a helpful way, it just made it feel like a hodgepodge. Also, didn't like the sections of the Atlantic portrayed in art and literature. Really disliked the comparisons between coastal cities. There were too many personal anecdotes.
A different structure instead of the Shakespearean reference.
Less personal information and much less about how certain experiences affected the author. The personal commentary seemed out of place at times. I appreciate the author's appreciation of things, but seemed over-sentimental.
I love Simon Winchester as a narrator. Great voice. The only times I didn't care for the narration was during the sentimental portions-a little too affected.
Overall, yes. Some interesting and important information. You just have to push through the sentimentality and the topics that don't really fit.
Simon Winchester is an excellent author and narrator. This book was good but it could have been amazing. He is so talented imparting information about history and science, but I find him less talented as an essayist.
Another excellent book and well told story by Simon Winchester. His language is impeccable, and his research is unsurpassed. I was truly enriched by taking the time to listen to this book.
The top audiobook I have listened to so far, and like the other Winchester books, I have learned a great deal and his books always seem to help my understanding the world.Bravo! and Aldas, bekesseg!
I first became acquainted with Simon Winchester when I listened to him read his book Krakatoa several years ago. Since that time, I think I've enjoyed all of his audio book presentations. Atlantic is one of the best.
Many of his works have a geology story associated with them - and the connections between geology the subject of the book are fascinating. He has a gift for sharing insights about phenomena that leave the listener wondering - "I never knew that - why haven't I heard that before".
I've grown to love Simon Winchester's writing style - wrapping a thought in layers of adjectives to create a rich, thought-provoking visual picture of a concept he is teaching.
I really like the fact that this author reads his own works. His reading performance is wonderful and I never tire of hearing his personable, authentic and empathetic voice.
Atlantic weaves a fascinating story from the ocean's creation to its exploration and plundering by mankind. Simon Winchester explores the role of the Atlantic ocean in history and speculates about its future.
Take the opportunity to listen to this book, or any of Simon Winchester's other well-reseached books to learn much from this master teacher.
Simon Winchester has once again, researched in depth, and found a great theme. He has personalized it with his own experience, and turned in a superb performance!!
The way it explained changes in the earth and some of the consequences past and possible future.
At the end of the book when the writer goes to the site of a naval disaster and what he finds, the whole story of the calamity and the timeline made it very real.
When the writer described the scene of one of mans first communities near the ocean.
No, I think it would have been too much for one sitting.
This book got me thinking of the present changes in our weather patterns and what might be causing the changes, man VS nature.
I loved Simon Winchester’s Krakatoa and thought I would like this as well. Unfortunately I found it unfocused and didn't like the first few stories. I usually finish books I start, but I abandoned this one early on. Maybe it gets better further into it?
Simon Winchesters voice is a delight to listen though.
This book is easily among the 10 best audiobooks I own.
Simon Winchester tells a story like no one else writing today. His classical education simply sparkles in this book. He looks at the history and geography of an entire ocean and asks questions no one else would think of, and then goes on to answer them using the old oral tradition of true storytelling.
If you're not farmilliar with Simon Winchester, this is a good book to read as an introduction to his work. Atlantic will surprise you with how interesting a subject can be, when most of us would simply think of it as an ocean that we learned all we needed to know about years ago. If you don't purchase this book, do try something by Simon Winchester. You'll be glad you did.
This book is amazing. It covers a broad span of subjects with sufficient depth to be interesting. It is coherent, cogent and concise. It is also poetic and emotional without being sappy.
Simon Winchester at his best. If you yearned for more books like Outposts (30 years ago) then this is a treasure. The author has had 30 years to refine his already great skill with prose into a truly unique view of the Atlantic Ocean. A must read for everyone! William Manchester glanced off the topic in a World Lit By Fire but Winchester hits his target right on. I have an English professor friend who refuses to go on the the next Winchester book until she has relished every word. That person is now four books behind in reading and has yet to get to Krakatoa or the Man Who Loved China. What a loss.
Thank you Simon Winchester once again. Maybe a book about Chaucer and Phillipa next?