Absolutely, remembering that this is an engaging read and good for the cardio. A perfect treadmill book.
This book takes a simple parable approach to economics.
The scenes where donkeys were exchanged for Llamas as a fix for the "grass guzzling" carts.
This book is an earworm, you will find yourself quoting the book and applying the story to your daily life.
The way the two brothers made a imaginary story to convey their ideas
The ah's of understanding
Made me sick how our politicians play with us "peasants"
Great read to understand how the economy works and who is in charge.
relevant, easily explained great parable the more times you listen the more you learn
I loved this book and would listen to it again in a heart-beat. The analogy is entertaining, accurate and in many cases, quite funny. I found myself laughing out loud at the character names who represent real people from American economic history.
The readers (and authors) did an excellent job reading the story. Andrew Schiff read the analogy and Peter would jump in with a series of
The climactic ending was both dramatic and prophetic. I found myself loving the ending and hating it at the same time. I loved the irony but hate how tragic the ending is for the people in the book. The United States is on the same path as the people in the book unless policy makers hit the brakes on current policy and change direction.
The book is essentially a parable of the growth of an economy, and eventually the growth and 20th century crises of the American economy. I can't say that it taught me a lot I didn't already know, but it does provide lots of information in condensed form. The format of a parable helps to clarify the authors' points, however it might also over-simplify, and make it easier to ignore points that might not fit with the authors' viewpoint. The points made do feel over-simplified at-times, and a slightly deeper discussion would have helped.
Their viewpoint, by the way, is quite reasonable - that the idea that consumer spending (fuelled by government-backed cheap credit) can be an engine of economic growth is an absurdity. Economic growth has to be based on actual production. They heavily criticize the US administration's response to the current crisis (throwing more money at the market, and pushing even more cheap credit - that caused the crisis in the first place). The essence of their argument is that the heavy government meddling in the market is at-least partially responsible for the meltdown, and that their response prevents the market from healing - the companies/people who made foolish choices, like trying to "flip" investment homes, should pay the price, instead of transferring their mistakes to all tax-payers.
Even if you don't fully agree with their analysis, this is an enjoyable listen, and I recommend it.
My 9 year old son started listening to this with me. He said "Dad so the fish is money?" and then put his book down and listened on our 2 hour road trip. I love it when a book can be both educational and fun and the topic be something important and usually dry like economics. Thank you for the excellent book.
If it had been grounded in real economic theory instead of political fantasy
Not have written it so I woiuld not have wasted my money
The argument of this book: we can go back to the wonderful days of the 18th century with a few extremely rich and everyone else very poor, if only we could abolish government (except for law enforcement.) The writers, like many right-wing extremists, fail to understand that in a world of so many firearms, their policies would lead to social revolution and the destruction of the very capitalism they worship.
and other Cato Institute crap, you'll love this. Lots of theory based around a lame story of three guys on an island. i.e. no references to the real world. They bill it as a fun, entertaining story. It's not. It's dull. I could only get through the first three chapters. Bleech.
A less self-righteous attitude, a less ridiculous plot... I don't know what to say, it's just so far off reality.
The way they try to portray "real" characters as "fictional" characters and their total lack of distance to the subject on which they are writing.
Sure... whatever, it's not part of the plot.
Everything! Really, everything!
The actual reading is not that bad (good thing they picked the right Schiff to do the voice). I'm by no means an opponent to capitalism or an open market. But the way the Schiffs whine about the current state of the economy, and how much better it would be if Keynes hadn't come along. Pathetic, really.
The large portion of how an economy really is built, i.e the first nine chapters, is not something I would debate too loudly. But then it goes from bad to piss-my-pants bad. Don't waste your money, and don't waste your time. There are far better books to read and/or listen to.
I shouldn't have trusted the high reviews on this one, thanks a lot, stupid review-system.
Say something about yourself!
Schiff does a great job of explaining how an economy is created from production and exchange. Then he goes on to explain how government activities disrupt production in favor of consumption. Everyone should listen to this. It is a better introduction than I received the 2 graduate-level economics classes I took from a major university.