I've read the other books in this series and enjoyed them much more than this book. I think the problem was more with the narration than the story. The reader made it difficult to focus on the story because I found myself being distracted by her intonation.

I have the softest spot for Tracker. I am so happy Ari was for him. They complimented each other very well. I loved it. Cant wait for Shadow's story.

This was a great book. I've listened to all 4 Hell's Eight books and loved every one of them. Hope Audible gets more Sarah McCarty books. The Promises series would be a good start. Can't wait for Shadow's Stand to come out.

I love the combination of period and erotica and those sexy boyz deliver every time

The narration of this book was awful! I had to stop listening several times, just because it was so boring. It's almost like Ari has NO personality at all...its bizarre. The characters don't develop in a way that you feel like you know or enjoy them. If you like sex scenes its alright, but sounds like every other that the author writes so of course you know whats coming...apparently the author has a "thing" for anal stuff. So far I have listened to two books of hers and both make the biggest deal out of anal sex. Needless to say I'm glad its over, and that I don't have to listen again, and won't be buying any more McCarty books.

This is a great story...but the narrator is TERRIBLE! I would suggest reading the book rather than listening. The narrator seems to phrase all of her sentences kind of like a question and draws the words out. I would have rated with 5 stars if it weren't for the narrator.

Love the Hell's Eight boys. I so looked forward to finding Ari and this would have been a fantastic Audible book except for the narrator. Every sentence spoken sounded like a question. Very irritating.

While Tracker's Sin isn't as bad as the Tucker's Claim ( the previous book of this series - awful! ), it still doesn't live up to the quality of Caine's Reckoning (the first book). For me, this book teetered between just ok and boring. I guess I was expecting more since the female lead in Tracker's Sin (Ari) was the twin sister of the female lead in Caine's Reckoning (Desi). But this book lacked the spark of the first story. I see other reviewers don't agree with me on this, but I was disappointed with this installment (again!).

The narration was also off, which certainly didn't help matters. These "Hell's Eight" characters are supposed to be the epitome of rugged cowboys, and yet the narrator portrays them like rejects from Gunsmoke or Bonanza. Shouldn't those issues be addressed in production?

Agree with other reviewers that while this story was good, it needed more story development. At this point in the series, it would have been good to extend the story once they returned to Hell's 8. Tracker and Ari's relationship needed more time as did Ari and Desi. Plus the whole storyline around killing the bad guy was short changed.

I would rather have read this book on my own than listen to her narration.
Ari sounds tired ALL THE TIME!
I can understand Tracker's low voice, but there is no feeling in Ari's voice that shows any personality that I know she has.
I'm so disappointed.
Take my advice. Buy the book and read it yourself.