I just completed all 3 books in the series and enjoyed them. Narrator Shawn Pratt got on my nerves at first but in the long run his voice was comfortable. I would have liked more time devoted to Hitler but that's just my preference. Also, much time was given to details of how Nazism effected every aspect of life. I wearied at times anxious to get to the next segment or chapter. I am thankful that when describing the treatment of the Jews' persecutions, tortures, and deaths Evans used restraint. In other words he could have been much more graphic describing rapes and tortures. The imagination can take care of what is lacking.
I like the fact that he portrayed the leaders of Nazism as brute beast worthy of the worst punishments for the horror for which they were responsible Nevertheless, no book or books will EVER capture the summary of evil that took place in Europe during WWII.
Very compelling stories. Makes you aware of how once evil has taken hold, it holds fast and takes everything down. Personally i thought this was much better than the shrier history (even if less technical).
If you are interested in another chestnut about what those horrible Nazis did to those poor innocent Jews, you'll love this. If you're looking for a well researched account of National Socialist Germany during the 1939-1945 period you will be sickened by the B.S. you will be forced to endure.
This needs to be re-labelled as the propoganda it actually is.
I just finished the last book of Richard Evans three volume compilation. After reading Shire's "Rise and Fall of the Third Reich", I must say Evans has done a fantastic job of depicting life during Nazi Germany on all fronts, and explains in detail the extreme miserable conditions of the Jews, poles and the sacrifices all of Europe faced during this period. Great books and a very detailed history of the Third Reich during this time. Tony C.
For anyone with even a passing interest in world history. This book is a much deeper dive into Nazi Germany's war than just the tactical outcome of battles. Evans meticulously and often painfully reconstructs the horror that was among the most murderous and evil regimes in human history.
Beautifully read and beautifully written. You get a good picture of what life was like in Nazi Germany during the war.
I've been a member a lot longer than one year--that is all.
Top-notch; ranks among the best history books I've ever read.
The content is arranged so that various topics are related together rather than haphazardly all in a jumble. Of course this makes for a bit of repetitiveness, but the overall clarity is worth it.
Narration is extremely professional and fits the subject matter in tone and inflection. I noticed that the narrator occasionally pronounced the same words (usually names) differently, but that didn't bother me since I don't know the correct pronunciation for those words anyway.
Yes. It took me a while to break free of the Civil War narrative that I knew him for, but overall I felt his delivery was good.
This book contains a wealth of information in support of the military narrative. I say "in support of" because the detail associated with the military battles and campaigns is minimal when compared to other writers like Beevor or Keagan. What you will find is the underlying policies, intrigues and social/economic/political environment that is the setting for the military actions. Truly German-centric, enough of the broader context was provided to keep things relatively well rounded. For those who know nothing of the individual battles and campaigns, you will not find the details here. For those who do know the details, this provides an often missing context.
I will echo one complaint of another reviewer: common German terminology. At first I thought this criticism was petty, but it really did start to bother me as the book progressed. "The Leader" instead of "the fuhrer". The "military SS" instead of the "Waffen SS", even going so far as to translate the names of the SS units to "Greater Germany" instead of "Das Reich", "Death's Head" instead of "Totenkopf", or the one that really drove me crazy was "Personal Flag unit of Adolf Hitler" instead of the "Liebstandarte Adolf Hitler". At moments like these, I felt like I was listening to a poor Google translation of the book. Does it make a big difference? To me, not really, as I am aware of what is talking about most of the time. But for those who are not familiar with the terms, they may be increasingly confused when they do further study and encounter the German terms...as they will with just about any other history text on this subject.