I made it most of the way through Part One of this three part audiobook. The narrator was a little whiny, but I don't blame him because the book is VERY whiny. After 8 hours I have no idea what this book is about. It seems to be telling the story of a woman who shares my age, my ethnicity, my social standing, much of my history, so if I found it totally unappealing, for whom was this massive volume written? Dull dull dull. The writing is a snorefest and the characters would be better off joining a suicide cult or going to work for the GOP. Anything would be interesting. Maybe Audible will refuse this review because I didn't finish the book but nobody should be compelled to make that sacrifice. They should be happy I didn't ask for my credit back.
If it weren't for Audible I'd never get any reading done.
There are beautiful and heartbreaking passages in this novel, but far too many wasted pages (or wasted listening hours) on cardboard characters in banal situations. The section on the main characters' college years rang true, but I couldn't for one minute believe the passages about their son, or the young Indian woman, or the quixotic career one of them takes up about 2/3 through. The adulation this book is getting seems well out of proportion.
The reader deserves special criticism for the sing-song, whiny voice he adopts, especially when in the voice of the female lead.
Typical cat lady: lazy, sings off-key, craves spicy bloody marys.
1. simply glorious writing
2. unflinching (gulp)
3. observations that take you down the rabbit hole
4. lingers in your mind waaaaaay past the end
5. you may ultimately treat people with more deference
Audible Member Since 2003
Like the rest of the world, I was very much looking forward to the release of Jonathan Franzen's new novel FREEDOM. In one sense, I was not disappointed, and Franzen continues to prove his writing prowess is no fluke. FREEDOM is chock full of the crazy family dysfunctionality that we grew to love in THE CORRECTIONS, actually a good bit more of it. And that might be the slight problem with this book - too much of it. When sometimes less is more, FREEDOM heaps on nutcase after nutcase.
The characters in this book are very believable and we all know and/or are related to them. We just prefer not to know them too well. Still, I enjoyed this book a lot and would recommend it, but not quite at highly as Franzen's previous and best book.
I tried to listen for one hour. Then I tried to listen for another hour. I quit listening. I did not like any of the characters. The writing seems shallow and the characters were not interesting. The plot was uninteresting.
The most over-rated novel in many years. Annoying, cynical, smarter-than-thou, full of cheapshots. The characters have zero appeal. I might have tolerated the book a slight bit better had it not been for the fact that it was read by The World's Worst Narrator. If he doesn't annoy you at first, I guarantee he will! Listening to him after awhile sounded and felt like fingers on a blackboard. Full Disclosure: Didn't get beyond twentysome chapters but my days have lifted considerably since I stopped listening.
I hear voices. But maybe that's because there's always an Audible book in my ear.
So, 20-some hours later, I'm at the end of Freedom. I found the characters and their lives to be completely boring. I didn't hate the narration, but tired of the run-on sentences delivered with the same monotony of the characters. This book could easily have been half the length and still delivered whatever it set out to do. It was a disappointment and a waste of a credit.
I read Corrections and I found it interesting. I only got through 1/3 of
Freedom:A Novel. It just became tedious. (Considering all the fanfare, I'm wondering "what's wrong with me?") I found Jonathan Franzen a poor man's John Updike. Thought the reader was just so so.
I'm sorry to say this, but this book sucked! There is not a single character who is likable, everyone is a deciever and a cheat. Totally evil and self centered. I could not finish it, and I wish I could return it. Lousy listen!