I enjoy many types of books and am always looking for new authors to read and listen too. I enjoy reading the reviews and adding my own from time to time.
I have listened to this audio three times already. I love the story and the narration. It is easy to follow and of course I love the continuation from book 1 of the Wallflower series, Secrets of a Summer Night. Knew that Lillian and Westcliff were destined for each other.
The hunt where Lillian goes against what Marcus, the Earl of Westcliff has told her to do. She is so hard headed to anything he tells her to do. I enjoyed the scene where she gets her finger stuck in a bottle of brandy while trying to get the pear out of it. Marcus of course helps her get the bottle loose and it turns into a full blown love scene.
Her inflections for each of her characters is always well done and makes it easy to distinguish who is who. Her voices for women and men are just different enough to make them easy on the ear.
I did and continue to do so each time I listen to it.
Not at this time.
I could not stop listening to this book! What a great series! Lisa Kleypas is a wonderful writer and the author does an outstanding job. You feel like your right there with the Wallflowers! Love It!
She makes you feel like your right there with them!
A Must Read!
Researcher, editor, writer, francophone, anglophile. Started listening to audiobooks to conciliate my love of knitting and novels.
This is my first Wallflowers Kleypas novel, but it won't be my last. I'm already listening to Devil in Winter (Wallflowers n. 3).
The love story is totally believable in this one. I liked the main characters' strengths and weaknesses. The opening scene was original as well. I would recommend this one for lovers of historical romance.
"I wear a fez now, fez's are cool"
I would recommend this because of the male character and that it is part of a greater series.
I liked the hero greatly and the interaction with the other wallflowers as well as the introduction of Sebastian. The twist at the end was also interesting.
When she was drunk.
I did laugh.
Lillian is not a great heroine, she is bossy, rude, obnoxious and way over the top, in the other books she is down right awful at times. Kleypas did tone her down a bit, but unfortunately this is the one time I am not a fan of Rosalyn's narration, her American accent doesn't help the overall dislike I have for the heroine. I probably disliked her more because of it. Rosalyn does an amazing job at other times but for some reason the way she voiced Lillian just made me really not care for her.
It's quite possible I just really don't like the character of Lillian, in Scandal in Spring I down right hated her so perhaps that is tainting this review.
What makes this book good is everyone else and the times when Lillian is not annoying. The twist was interesting and Westcliff is one of my favorite hero's.
Worth a listen.
The producers erred terribly in hiring Rosalyn Landor because
1) She can't do an American accent.
2) Her male voices sound like the voice you make when you drop your chin into your neck and make as silly a deep voice you can.
The pity is that the protagonist for this book is American and a New Yorker (I'm both) yet sounds exactly like someone parodying a flat, part faux-midwestern, part cowboy accent with the most rollings R's I've ever heard a Brit or American bother with. Lillian and her sister sound like they should be riding mules and shooting their pistols instead of coming out of New York society.
You can imagine how scenes of ardor sound when a woman sounds like a cowgirl and a man sounds like a kid pretending to be a man. The declarations of passion are absolutely hilarious and ridiculous, and I found all the male characters very difficult to take seriously because they sounded so awful.
If you can get over these two things and are a fan of Lisa Kleypas, then I guess it's a fine read. Try not to laugh.
There was much less story in this one compared to the first in the series. While I enjoyed listening to Lillian and Marcus discover their mutual passion, it almost got to be predictable and boring to listen to the same thing over and over again in great detail. After the third time, I wished I could have fast forwarded through it.
Audio-fiction ADDICT !
The hero and heroine were just AMAZING! I loved Lilian's character! It was a really sexy book. Rosalyn again well done.
There were moments of pleasure, but it did not make up for the hours of boredom... I like Kleypas' novels - mostly - but was disappointed in this one. It was a painfully predictable, and typical "they loved each other, but won't admit it" for chapter after chapter after chapter... Only while they are being DENSE, nothing really happens.
There are dinner parties, and dances and clandestine groping, but not much else. The way the heroine, Lillian, behaves throughout the story is beyond irritating. She is supposed to be independent and headstrong - like that's a good thing - but with her, it's like watching peevish, adolescent rebellion. She is a shrill brat. I really could not figure out what Marcus saw in her.
The last bit of the story is good... but at that point, it was not enough to redeem the investment of time and money. Overall, it was NOT worth it.
I picked this book because I read the first "Wallflower" story, "Secrets of a Summer Night," and enjoyed it. I was very impressed with the narrator, and her ability to do so many different accents and characters. But, she really needs to work on making her American accents more pleasant. Her rendition of Lillian is shrill and grating. That alone was enough to make Lillian hard to like, but combine that with her outrageous, cringe-worthy behavior... Pass.
I read so I can write
This second in the series continues to be entertaining and really fun. These women are so great and the stories that Kleypas weaves around them are excellent. Can never say enough about a good narrator and Landor is one of the best.
A book lover with a romantic soul, but willing to take a leap of faith. I LOVE to get sucked into a story and live there for a bit.
I Love this story and the narrator does a great British woman and man, BUT when the "American accent" comes around it is SO HORRIBLE that it almost ruins the book for me. I know we have different accents but come on! It sounds like a modern woman who was placed into the 1800's and it just doesn't fit. It is SO BAD that I almost don't want to finish, but I really am enjoying the book. I would recommend the BOOK but the narration is a bit hard to swallow. It makes it hard to get lost in the story like I do for so many of the other stories that I listen to. I usually listen while I do chores or drive but the American voices make me not proud to be an American (It is a bit grinding, which I know they think is how we sound, but I hope and pray I don't really sound like I have a corn cob shoved up my hoo-ha!)