While I haven't read the print version, I can't imagine how the experience can possibly be any more fullfilling than what I got from this audio book.
Hitlers early Vienna days and his first years as a politician leading up to the Beer Hall Putsch was absolutely fascinating, even though I knew much of the story already. For learning purposes I would have to say the chapters about economy and living standards in the Third Reich were great sources of information for me.
I would imagine a lot. Of all the audiobooks in my library, this is hands down the best narrated of them all. A master of his craft.
The personal tragedies in this story are too many to count. But I can't look past the Polish people and the hell they lived under throughout this phase in history. Horrific stuff.
Comprehensive. Detailed. Emotional.
For me, Grover Gardner is the best narrator of non-fiction material. His voice, his tone, and his pace are all perfect.
I find this book really extraordinary. First, I was rather put off by the length. Then when I started, I was captivated. The book tells the story of the rise of Nazis from the perspective of someone who was a direct witness of the beginning of the tragedy. It is very well written and narrated.
It reminds one how terribly actual it is. Would Europe be able to stop a similar development if it were to arise now? It makes you think, remember recent tragedies like Yugoslavia, and see the events in Crimea in different light. And it makes you realize how special the time we live in is.
It is not an amusing book but it is really great and should be read by as many people as possible. Some parts made me literally shudder, and so they should.
I enjoy history, biographys, and nerdy/ dorky things.
Masterful, detailed, sad
I've never read anything this detailed before. At 57 hours it is a masterpiece of history.
Yes, I listened to Titan, a biography about John. D. Rockefeller. Grover Gardner has a fantastic voice, and again does a great job with this book.
In school we were taught about the horrors of the 3rd Reich. However learning of these horrors through the written letters, and reports of SS, and Gestapo officers is very sad. Not just because of the crimes, but that human beings could treat other human beings so, in-inhumanely.
Any book this long has it's slow points. In section 3 or 4 the book really slows down. This is dedicated entirely to Germany acquiring Austria, and Czechoslovakia. This was the only issue I had with the book. I didn't think 8 hours needed to be spent on such a subject. Learning about Hitler's upbringing, background, soaring victories, and finally embarrassing defeats were a joy to listen to.
Yes, I preferred the audio version since the length of this book made it hard to read.
His voice is perfect for narration. The cadence and speed was great. He put pauses and emphasis in just the right places to draw your attention to certain points and it made it more engaging to listen.
The portion regarding the concentration camps and resistance movements understandably are difficult to listen to.
As has been previously mentioned on several websites - this book contains some very prejudiced and bigoted statements. Remember that it was written in 1960 and it thus contains the mentality and paradigm from that era.
The narrator is superb, and the content chilling. As German democracy, then Austria, then Czechoslovakia and then Poland fell, I wanted to scream "Can't you see what's happening?"
Hitler was insane. That would be a three word summary of a 57 hour book.
Claus von Stauffenberg- a hero. When someone finally stands up and says, enough: "This must stop even if it costs my life." That's a hero. This part of the book read like fiction.
Molotov is pretty good. A calculator in the line of great Soviet chess players, many moves ahead of his competition.
The jewish revolt in Krakow moved me to tears.
Give it a listen, you won't regret it. Only criticisim is Shirer's homo prejudices. Maybe a sign of the times, but he ably shows the Nazis to be thugs, criminals and psychopaths. Didn't need to call them perverts, too (without mentioning the "perverts" on the Allied side).
I realised I had never done any serious reading/listening on WWII history. To cure my ignorance I bought The Rise & Fall of the Third Reich, and 57 hrs 13 mins later, I do not regret the decision at all. I was a bit suspicious that I might feel like I had done enough in the WWII department after this book, but now having completed it, my interest has grown and not diminished. I highly recommend this book.
This must rank amongst the top histories available on Audible.
Among the best.
The inside details from beginning to end
I would recommend to a friend but only one that its a history buff like myself .
I enjoyed how factual and in depth the story was .
There is no way you could finish this all at once .
Iranians keep their nukes, Americans lose their insurance.
No book other than the bible has ever moved me like this one. My father was a POW and fought in the war, and he said this book is the launch code for Nazi Germany. He was right. I got this book because it was 1 credit. Only 1 credit for 57 hours! God bless Mr. Shirer and... Grover Garder you are amazing. Amazing! Bill Shirer would have been proud.