I reference both frequently
The identification of humility as a quality of great leaders was life changing for me. Starting a new journey for me to find grace in my life.
This book helped me shape my perspective on everything from staffing to core business strategy. Moreover, it found a relatively entertaining way of doing it.
Lust for Life
It was pretty bland, though the book was so bad, I don't see a way of making it better.
I was frustrated by the ridiculous conclusions the author came up with based on highly flawed research, which itself was based on shaky premises. The idea that you can measure a company's "greatness" by its stock price set the stage for a highly disappointing book. I think the author actually set out to prove the hypothesis that a "level 5 leader" could turn a good company into a great company. Therefore, the so called research was designed to demonstrate this.
The research methods used were incredibly flawed and some of the conclusions the author drew were truly baffling. There were many inconsistencies, such as when he lauded one company for breaking away from its core business ("selling the mills"), then later criticizing another for doing essentially the same thing. He also annoyed me every time he referred to the "hedgehog concept." It was pretty obvious that the author wanted to coin a phrase, based on a story he told, because he repeated the phrase over and over, even though he applied it inconsistently. Anyway, the proof is in the pudding since some of the companies he held up as great (Circuit City, Wells Fargo, Fannie May), actually became epic fails or would have if the government didn't bail them out. The author tried to cover himself by saying that his conclusions were based on the condition of the companies' stock prices during particular periods of time. What a cop out! During the time periods, he surveyed these companies, the seeds for their failure were already being sown. Anyway, I could go on and on. Do yourself a favor and don't bother with this book.
Book acts the part in trying to teach rigorous leadership style, and I think some readers will over indulge to their demise. Book tries to wrap itself around success companies and then wrapping it's material around that to sell principles. Book lacks creditability on the principles.Disciplined people and companies are all around us...KPI's are everywhere. I know a major brand that has no discipline and they are growing and have been for decades. It's really the right strategy and flywheels that work, not always the points being sold in the book - at least to me. The Crocker example is a bad one, Well's is not the best of employers - what is Well's turn over rate!
Chapter one, I just skipped it completely. No learning. Too much over-indulging in interviews. Kind of like author was trying to be a Steve Covey and missed.
I think what stuck out to me about Good to Great, was Jim Collin's unbiased review of the data. He willingly stepped away from his personal feelings about leadership, and opened up a great discussion on what makes a "level five"/Great leader.
I appreciate this information, especially after working under all types of leaders. It helps you discern from the qualities that appear to get some ahead in the game, from the ones that will actually benefit the company long-term. Jim recognizes in his findings that there are "great" leaders out there everywhere, there just simply isn't enough recognition in placing them in the right decisions. This is a great book for anyone in hiring, leadership, or aspiring to be a leader!
I feel with all the readily available 'inspiration' online, there wasn't a ton of value here.
Disappointment in not choosing a better read.
clear easy to understand concepts
Right people on the bus and wrong people off the bus
The People on the bus
Yes. No matter if you are an entrepreneur or an aspiring corporate executive, this book has great ideas that can apply in your business life.
"First who, then what"
Must read. Despite its research-based background (which gives it much validity), Jim Collins narrates and brings the book to life, even when describing their research methodology.
The companies for the most part failed in time....
The reading was fine.... I got sucked in for a while
All of the companies that failed in the 15-20 year period
Live a double life, in the morning and afternoon I am a very geek developer and entrepreneur, but at night I become a clown for my 3 kids :)
Definitely Jim Collins has to be a great teacher, knowledgable in the field with a great research team. These audiobooks are the most incredible business book I ever listened to. All the stories and comparison are accurate, adding the amazing narrator of the book, Jim Collins, the author.
It is hard to say, this book is not about an specific character, is an insight about companies that went from being good to being great. Every story is an amazing experience.
Good to Great, there's never a final approach when you're aiming to greatness!
These set of audiobooks are the most essential business tool any entrepreneur most have. All the research is an amazing journey towards greatness. This is definitely the perfect complement to Think and Grow Rich from Napoleon Hill.