In the introduction the writer said words to the effect that there is a four-word question that a good storyteller hopes will enter the mind of the reader. The question is "And then what happens".
Unfortunately, the four-word question that entered MY mind while listening to this book was "What was the point?"
I found perhaps 3 or 4 of the stories mildly engaging, and I listened to the bitter end out of stubbornness and the hope it would get better. It didn't.
I actually purchased this title on the strength of the fact that one of my favorite authors - Joe Hill - was among the writers. What I didn't realize is that his was the very last of the short stories, and it only ran slightly over 30 minutes. While that piece was okay, it wasn't really worth suffering through the other 17 hours and 45 minutes of less than stellar stories.
Some narrations and stories were spectacular. However some descended to a droll narrative, leading me to either skip to the next, or impatiently wait for the story to finish.
This collection of stories is frustrating and entertains. Frustrating in that it brings you to a certain point... And stops. The introduction is a clue: and then, what happened? You supply your own continuation of the theme. Very different concept in storytelling.
An extreme mix of interesting, well-written stories and overwrought, badly-written cheese, with more of the latter than the former. A few of the narrators are particularly awful, one does a terrible fake southern accent for every story, another does a clipped toneless robotic voice, and another chooses the oddest inflections that make no sense.
Like Audio books, love to be read to. Am retired, spend a lot a time at pool so listen to music, & audio books when have them, now I will have ones I like.
Least is some of the stories were to short, 6 minutes here & there. Some an hour. More was likes than some, but so many to name best, do not remember the titles. Am still finishing up the stories.
Well reminded me more of Hitchcock stories leaves you wondering
Well since so many stories was listening 1 after another, so do not remember titles
Yes May Be
This set of stories is very well narrated, but the actual tales are either not interesting or have no closure. There were 3-4 stories that were captivating, but then I was disappointed when they would stop at some arbitrary point with no real ending. I kept asking "But what happened after THAT??" Neil Gaiman mentions the concept of "what happens next?" as an essential part of a good story, but I also prefer stories that have some sort of ending, even if it is just "They lived happily ever after" or "And he was never seen again..."
Definitely recommended due to the variety of the subject matter and the audio delivery of the short stories. Every one of the stories were well written and worth listening to both in terms of content and the enthusiasm shown by the narrators in their delivery. All the stories had my interest, most often in terms of the descriptive text, dialogue and interest build up.
There were a number of memorable moments in all the stories due to the excellent nature of the delivery. Specific stories that had a good build up to the climax were The Truth is a Cave in the Black Mountains in which the story and characters followed a journey which included many questions raised. Let the Past Begin builds up through a number of humorous but favorable observations of the girlfriend, with some amusing, but well written dialogue, plus brings in an interesting theme with respect to unusual occurrences.
All the narrators were enthusiastic about their subject material. Most had interesting accents that suited the story and provided greater variation. Interestingly, they were forthcoming in changing accents with new characters in the story and this most often added value to the story line. I particularly enjoyed the change from male to female vocalization in Let the Past Begin as well as the Scottish accents in The Truth is a Cave in the Black Mountains.
Clearly, a single tag line is difficult for a book on short stories: Mysteries Extraordinary
I have found this short story book particularly enjoyable. My thought is that it would be useful to have a downloaded and printable PDF that provides information on each of the short stories especially with respect to title and author. Perhaps a very short description would also be useful. I would expect the description may be useful for novels as well. I was going to rate the performance down to a four on this factor i.e. the fact that with audio one does not have a record of the chapters names etc. in the same way that one would have with a hard-copy, instead I have rated performance at a five with the recognition this is a technical matter for Audible to consider for the future.
Probably not from the authors- definitely not from the narrators
Very poor accents that were mostly stereotypical and grated on my nerves.
Most of the stories. There were only a few that were good, and on them the narration was bad.
There were a few good stories, so I kept listening, but most were disappointing and some were really awful!
If you are a Neil Gaiman fan like me, you might have some expectations for these stories, in which case you might be in for a bit of a shock. I have not finished all of this by any means yet - but the first 2 or 3 tales were a bit of a shock - stronger language and subject matter than I was prepared for. I'll come back and say more when I'm done...