This is just a superb book. The narration and structure of the story were just terrific. I would recommend to anyone who has an interest in early 19th century American history..
My family and I have been "fans" of Quanah Parker for some time. Even where I thought I already knew the story, Gwynne provided additional fascinating detail. And there were many new stories I had never heard. I now drive around Texas with new eyes.
The result is as close to an immersion in the Comanche experience as an armchair gringo is likely to get. I listened with a mixture of revulsion at their brutality and respect for their mastery of plains life and fierce determination to defend their way of life. And Quanah's transformation to a "bloodthirsty" businessman who impoverishes himself caring for others left me wishing I had known the man.
Was sad when the book ended.
I listened to this wonderful book by Gwynne and then I bought a three copies of the book. One for me to read after listening and two to give away. Gwynne lets the reader into the Comanche culture--the violent nomadic horse culture. After two readings I really appreciate the loss of a way of life that ended as the primitive horse plains Indians were forced onto reservations.
Great history, great story. I recommend this book to any interested in the give and take of the real history of North America
A great tale well told. Even-handed depiction of the inherent conflict in the clash of two cultures radically different from one another. The author depicted the Comanches in all their cruelty and brutality but with a sympathy for their plight. There are no heroes nor villains here, but there is plenty of heroic and villainous activity. Superb reader. I couldn't stop listening.
This book is amazing. I couldn't stop listening. It's a good combination of story and history. The author brings it all alive.
I have read and listened to hundreds of books and this is one of my top five. This type of book is unique in my reading /listening experience in that I have, priror to this, exclusively been into mystery/espionage type fiction. I found this absolutely facinating. Only shortcoming was my not being able to "picture" the setting/geography involved. Does the hardback include this? If so, I will buy it and read it. If not, can I download/view it somewhere?
Love to read, and Audible has made the two-hour daily commute enjoyable!
I had no idea how little I knew about the Commanches other than they were fierce warriors and feared by settlers. This book talks about the traditions, the history of the Cheyenne, other plains Indians and the Indian Wars that eventually moved many tribes to reservations.
I liked how Gwynne pushes people to not view traditions through our modern eyes, but also consider the violent natures of our ancestors (Celts, the inquisition). He has a balanced approach - the war attrocities of the Cheyenne and also the combating Texas Rangers and U.S. Cavalry. Gwynne also discusses the impact of changes in technology - like the Colt revolver.
The end of the book covers the role of Quanah Parker - son Cynthia Anne Parker who was kidnapped in a raid when she was young. When "rescued" later in life, she continuously tried to escape back to the Cheyenne. Parker and his mother are studies in adaptation. He learned the game, and played it well to the benefit of himself and his peoples. What I don't like is that because of the focus on Quanah, it brushes on this not being the case for the majority of Indians who changed their lives from nomadic hunters to farmers. But - that is a lot to ask of a very interesting book.
Yes! Anyone who likes the history of the West and history of war will like this book. If you are put off by graphic violence then you probably won't like this.
If you liked the Larry McMurtry books like Comanche Moon and Dead Man's Walk you will love to hear what really happened and how close Larry McMurtry helped people get an idea of what it was like back then. You also keep realizing who he based characters on sometimes even by name.
When I first turned this on, I said outloud, "What in the world! This better be a great story with that kind of narration." Seriously, the documentary droning of the narrator was a downer for the first half our or so of listening. As I contemplated deleting it and picking a new book, I got into the story and I completely forgot about the voice telling it as I looked forward for each opportunity to plug in my ipod to my pickup stereo, or my home Bose, or my headphones, completely disregarding my initial impression of the reader.
I really loved the entire history lesson, felt enlightened with each chapter, becoming completely engrossed in the stories, descriptions and characters. This is the history lesson I never learned about indiginous peoples of "The West" and one that deserves study and acclaim in schools. This book describes how the country was effected and absent is the judgement of either side, just a outlay of facts and the fiction much of the old school history books and movies are based on.
I listened as intently as I had to "The Kitchen House", and absolutely recommend this to those interested in "The West" and how we came to be as a result of it.