I love Civil War stories, and this one does not disappoint - there is brutal detail in the story that only reminds us that a mere century and a half ago (or so) we were a savage people who did nnot understand the importance of basic hygiene, much less the equality of women (and race).
The narrator does make some mistakes that I feel were silly, but the story is not predictable and the heroine is not typical - these factors set this period piece apart from others set in this era.
In all, a story that is challenging, yet intriguing, fulfilling, yet merciless in the details of war. This book is not for the feint of heart, but is satisfying if you stay with it.
Hoosier transplanted in Virginia Beach who is a fan of good books and travel.
Mary Sutter wants to be a surgeon. Then the Civil War gives her the opportunity. This book presented a stark, and most likely accurate, horrific picture of the Civil War. This was a time when modern medicine was In Its infancy. The setting is interesting, but the fictional characters were not as appealing as they might have been.
I don't know if it was the narrator, or the book itself, but the entire thing was a depressing mess of the same theme- war is horrible, death is horrible, life is horrible- over and over and over. Nothing EVER good happens to the main character until the epilogue. I get that not every book has to be happy and peppy, I get that the Civil War was horrible, I just didn't need it told to me over and and over. Kimberly Farr's narration was slightly nasty and off putting. I doubt I'd ever buy another audio book with her as narrator. On a positive note- I did learn things about medical care during the Civil War that I did not know (assuming they are true) and it gave a very clear, stark picture of what being in the army was like. My hearts go out to those who died, even if it was so long ago. Their suffering must have been hell.