Trite and yammering, full of unnecessary and boring detail, and narrated by one of the worst readers I have ever heard: his voice is grating, he has no ability to effect different voices for different characters...and TOTALLY butchered the large amount of French in the book. It's inexcusable that someone with so little knowledge of or ability to speak a language as common as French should narrate a book like this. Who KNOWS what he did to the Hungarian?!
This book was so powerful that it drew out emotion from the deepest part of me at different points in the story. It is not just a story, it is THE story of a horrible time in humanity's history. But the author writes this story so beautifully and the characters are developed in such Detailed and pure way that you feel as if you were experiencing everything right there with them no matter how horrible it is. It is worth the read for it honors all who have come before us and the experience of World War II that was theirs. Blessings
Couldn't finish the book because of the narrator
I can only listen to this an hour at a time because of the narrator. Time will tell if the story is good enough to put up with it until the end.
The book has a lot of build up to the "action" of the war, and I've heard some negative comments about the sentimentality of the writing. However, I found it beautifully written and wonderfully performed!
This book contains a story that represents the experiences of my family during WWII and thereafter. While readers might believe it is fiction, to their dismay it is not. Incredibly written and read.
The prior reviews about the long droning narrator are correct. The story and writing this amazing epic novel is worth the hours of listening. A story centered in Hungry during WWII is less popular than than many of this genre. A spectacular novel of historical fiction, including love, action, crime, family dynamics, all during European unrest. I recommend this to a WWII fiction lover. A must. Yes narrator could be better, not the worst by far. Click purchase🙂
Most stories involving WWII in Europe contain dark themes and difficult to hear details. But This one is told with an incredibly interesting storyline of a young Hungarian Jew who begins as a student in Paris. Important historical fiction for us to hear again today and stay aware of to avoid past mistakes.
I cannot understand why this reader didn't pronounce so many words correctly. I would think that when preparing to do a story with so many unfamiliar words that you would do your homework. Really spoiled sections of this story for me.