This is a complex, interesting and ultimately very satisfying tale. It's well written and well read. That it's so long is a big plus.
I like to weed and read at the same time.
For me the narrator completely ruined this reading. His background voice has a nasal Birmingham twang to my ears,which has no place in a London based book and was completely distracting. His female voices are awful and irritating. I am spoiled by the TV series in which Linley and Havers are played to perfection. I would not read another Linley narrated by this reader.
Lots of suspects and subplots trying to lead you astray
As usual great performance with different voices for each of the characters.
Had difficulty putting it down; wanted to continue
You may want to listen to it again in fast speed to put it together after you know the ending.
great character development
good performance by the reader
minor thing, but the producer chose the worst and most menacing music, which really doesn't translate well to the few places it is heard. Ignore the music at the end- terrible placement and not relevant to what is actually happening.
Tantalizing, suspenseful mystery
Two stories side-by-side that became one ending
Narrator had no inflections in voice to such an extent that he put me to sleep!!!
Neither one but did have empathy for the prime character who tried to make a success of his life and never succeeded due to surrounding circumstances and people.
Better read than audio
This is my first Elizabeth George novel. The best thing about it, I thought (and I enjoyed the book a great deal), was the opportunity to go from mind to mind of the characters. I think George does a great job of integrating varying points of view and finding a balance between a novel that is driven by the plot (as is the genre of mystery) and involved in the reactions and thoughts of the characters. It's not particularly difficult to conjecture the "bad guy" but that seems to be ok with the author and was ok with me. The turns of the plot are not spoiled by having a sense of "who done it." There are enough hidden detail to make the who less compelling than the how. The book is well narrated and well paced. Good read.
I wonder if they are all this good. She builds a complex, multi-track mystery and pulls it all together very plausibly in the end. Like other reviewers I don't want to disclose too much about that. The surprises are a plus. George writes well, develops characters one cares about and it has made me want to read more of her books. Unfortunately Audible has few, and some are abridged. I wouldn't want to read an abridged version because I like the detail and character development.
John Lee is a favorite of mine and once again he does a good job. This may not have been the perfect book for his voice, but I'm so used to it, I just settle down with an old friend and let him read to me.
Beautifully written and read, the kind of audiobook that makes you miss your subway stop. Full of memorable set pieces and psychologically rich characters. My only disappointment is that I am not seeing any other Lynley novels: please put them all on audio!
I love Elizabeth George. And I really am not a fan of mystery novels. But George is smarter than I am...she keeps me guessing. Her characters are so well drawn and the first third of all her books keep me happily occupied for hours. And if, as is the fault of many in the mystery genre, the middle two thirds occassionally try my attention level, I am always drawn back in quickly via a twist in the plot or characters. Lynely is brilliant again, his usual erudite and urbane self, but a bit frayed around the edges due to his wife's murder two books ago. Havers is grumpy as ever and even the St. Johns make an appearance. This is not a series for those looking for an easy auditory "read". Sookie Stackhouse this ain't. But it is a well written mystery novel by a seasoned writer. George's heyday seemed behind her as far as I was concerned (I hated "Careless in Red" ~ Lynley was out of his element) but she seems to back with this book. I have read all of George's books and I heartily recommend her to fans of Stieg Larsson or P.D. James. This was a good book and a good audible reading. Although Simon Vance is my favorite, I thought John Lee did a very, very good job connecting with George's characters. Note: Even though I found the correlating story lines fascinating, one may be disturbing to some people. But if you got through any of Larsson's books you'll be fine.
This book is probably an excellent read, but it is not best suited for listening. The plot jumps around quite a bit, back and forth from various main characters and plot lines. This is a little hard to keep track of as an audio book. Also, the plot is a little slow getting started, presenting a lot of detail that only comes into play much later in the story. The abridged version may be a better listen.