Volume 1. Because it's the same characters and author.
nothing too unexpected
No mainly because the highlight of each short story is the plot and once you have the solution to each crime it would reduce the listening pleasure the second time
The structure of each story and the logic of each solution is brilliant
It is hard to separate one but the Hound of the Baskervilles is a standout
Because it is so long and is a number of short stories
Charlton Griffin has the most fabulous voice and his diction and slow delivery makes the book special
No, if a British reader of similar talent to Mr Griffin had been cast it would have been awesome, but his British accents are pretty lousy.
Every exposition of the breakdown by Holmes.
I loved the dramatic characterisation of the narrator, sadly let down quite severely by his shocking accents.
Holmes. Why? He's HOLMES.
If you're American or Canadian*, or English is your second language it is likely that this will rock for you. The dramatic performance is wonderful. Griffin is great in that sense. If you're Australian , Kiwi, or South African it will probably be a bit irritating that a British actor wasn't cast to read Sherlock Holmes. Such iconic Victorian literature should be authentic, not hammy.* In my experience North Americans don't pick up on the flaws in bad false UK accents in the way other English-speaking people do. That would have to be a blessing in this case :)
Really, what more can I say about a series so famous as this. The stories remain as entertaining today as they did when first written.
Again, Charlton Griffin preforms flawlessly. It is great he has stayed committed to the series, as changing narrators between volumes can be annoying.
The collection includes much of Doyle's best work and it felt like Christmas. Though I know all of the stories it was a treat listening to them again. The narration was brilliant!
Yes I would, specially because I find it to be interesting, well written and well narrated.
I strongly recommend Volumes 1 & 3 of The Complete Stories of Sherlock Holmes.
This is one of the best books that i have listened to
His voice fit the characters perfictly
The Hound of the Baskervilles might be my favorite Holmes story. I am a surprised fan. I definitely had a misconception of mystery novels. So even if you're not normally a fan of the mystery genre I strongly suggest a foray into Holmes.
I'm a big fan of si-fi, but I'm finding that a love for mysteries budding up in me. I also like a lot of nonfiction.
I once heard is said that the best characters are the ones with flaws. Sherlock Holmes is one of the best examples of that. He is eccentric. He is so obsessed with facts and practicality that he seem heartless. Ironically he is willing to go above and beyond for people who are more deserving of he services. Even to the point that he will of letting the criminal go free if the crime was, at least in Sherlocke's opinion, justifiable. He is also a bit egotistical, but is willing to set his ego aside and admit he was wrong at times. Worst of all, he is constantly criticizing Watson for his lack of deduction as well as other issues, but Watson is the only person Sherlock Holmes ever loved. For those of you who believe relationships are important in a story , the relationship between Holmes and Watson is the perfect example of how true love between men can happen without sexual attraction.
Yes. I enjoy the stories and the performance. The stories are interesting mysteries without being gory or dirty like so much of the modern writing.
Dr. Watson. He portrays the story in a humble way even when he puts himself at risk and helps to solve the cases.
The British accent that you would expect the characters to have as well as an American accent when the characters are American, etc.