Member since 2008, not 2015, as shown below.
I usually enjoy Ted Dekker's books, but this was the exception. My husband and I listened to it while traveling. It was actually hard to finish. The characters would have conversations and say the same things over and over and over and........I suggest you skip this one.
This story drew me in and kept me interested. It was clever and exciting. I would have liked to know a bit more background on the characters from the hospital but was entertained none the less.
The narrator was terrible. The cadence of his speech so slow I thought there was a problem with my device. I sped it up but wished for a better delivery thoughout.
Mainly how slow he spoke was the problem for me. He seemed to be trying to make the story more nerve racking with his pauses and droning tone.
No real plot twists. It's an okay story, I love some of the supporting characters. The diversity of voices was insufficient for the number of characters so many of the characters sound the same. Perhaps a female or a narrator with greater vocal range would have been better.
Not really. Although the story as a whole was good, the writing itself was weak. It was kind of painful to listen to at times. The characters were unrealistically flat, and none of them had any depth. The story was fun, which is why I give it 3 stars, but I was mostly disappointed.
No. See my notes above.
The narrator did a good job for the most part. There were a few times where he got his own voices for the different characters mixed up, but overall he kept it as interesting as he could make it.
The story? Yes. The writing? No.
Say something about yourself!
I really enjoyed the story and I loved that Ted Dekker used some brilliant mentally ill adults in the story. However, I wish Ted had studied more closely the laws on hospitalizing mentally ill patients against their will, giving medication against their will, lying about what one is giving the patient and restraining mentally ill patients. I also found it highly offensive that the director of the facility where these patients were found called the patients her "children." Even if a professional is extremely fond of a patient, adults want to be respected as adults even if they have a serious mental illness. All that said, I still enjoyed the book very much and I appreciated how Ted brought out the uniqueness, brilliance and beauty in each of the mentally ill characters. It was mostly a delightful read.
I'm listening to Proust now. Always on the lookout for a good zombie, horror, or sci-fi book. Like books on writing, history, travel.
Yes, I'm tired of writers going into the minds of the seriously disturbed. They often resort to some crazed version of religion, as in this book. I just don't believe it. There's also a very junior-high level love story here. I could finish the book. Came close, but couldn't do.
I'm open to any book as long as it is true to itself.
Aspects of this story were good, but overall it was very standard. I found that it was a bit insulting to mental illness - they just need a pat on the hand and to be told that they are pretty and they will be fine!
I have heard from others that Dekker can write better than this so I would try something else by him.
It is so much better than the print version. John Glover of Smallville fame (Yup I'm a nerd) has the perfect voice for this dark, intense, but hopeful performance.
I personally loved the development of the relationship between Brad and Paradise. It went from pittying a damaged girl, to being in awe of the differences between them.
I enjoyed the scene in the institute where Brad came in and had Paradise's rag tag band of misfits help with his investigation. It did a great job of being humorous, and humanizing at the same time. That is really hard to do when one is discussing mental illness. Nice work Ted!!!
Every time I had to get back to life stuff, I was hesitant. The way Dekker puts pen to paper makes you want to keep going. There are rarely, what I would call, good stopping points. An excellent problem to have as a listener!