A part-time buffoon and ersatz scholar specializing in BS, pedantry, schmaltz and cultural coprophagia.
"There was no filling the holes of death. The emptiness might be filled up by other things over the years -- new friends, children, new tasks -- but the holes would remain."
There have been books I've read fast before because they were exciting. There have been books that I've read before because they were funny. This is a book that was sad, moving, traumatic, large and important. I didn't nibble. I quickly gulped; cried, then gulped again. You can feel the soul that went into writing this book and the lives that went into giving this book meaning.
This novel belongs on the shelf strategically next to: 'War and Peace', 'The Things They Carried', 'For Whom the Bell Tolls', 'Red Badge of Courage', and 'The Naked and the Dead'.
I'm a 3rd into this story and so far its fascinating and enjoyable. The author has put a lot of little details of daily life which really puts you right there. The narrator is excellent and for the most part can tell the difference between the many characters in the story. My only issue is there are a lot of different characters in the story so you need to pay close attention in the beginning to know who they all are.
I have read and listened to a lot of Vietnam War books. Most have been from the perspective of the privates where all the officers are made to look like idiots who can care less. In this book the protagonists are young lieutenants, which make it a bit different and more realist view
Audible Member Since 2003
What a great book that could have been written only by a person who has lived through the experience. It is full of military jargon and certainly not for everyone. It is a hard-hitting account of the absolutely tragic futility known as Vietnam. The hill known as "Matterhorn" was just a hill occupied by the Marines, abandoned by the moronic command and re-taken at the immeasurable cost of human lives. This book is simply a masterpiece.
I hear voices. But maybe that's because there's always an Audible book in my ear.
I thought I had a tiny bit of an idea of what Viet Nam was about, but the deprivation and pain and horrific loss is clearer in this book than in anything else I've ever read. The characters are real: complex, lovable and frustrating. But, even more infuriating is the ridiculous loss of life and the horrible disservice our government did to an entire generation. This book is raw. It's also one of the finest things I've ever listened to. The dialogue and brilliant narration combine to make it feel all too real. I will never look at a Viet Nam vet the same.
I have many Gigabytes of Audible.com books & enjoy them all. This however leads the pack by far in the Military series. This is the only book that has moved me to write a review. It is worth every moment of listening. Spellbinding! Do yourself a favor, give it a try. John T. Wagner. 5 Stars easy
I drug my feet about listening to this one. Nam isn't exactly something fun to remember. However, once I started listening, I couldn't stop. The writing is excellent and narration is spot on.
After so much has been written about Nam, it's hard to believe one more book could add so much to understanding. History and military buffs will enjoy this book
Gen-Xer, software engineer, and lifelong avid reader. Soft spots for sci-fi, fantasy, and history, but I'll read anything good.
As powerful and readable a novel about being a grunt in the Vietnam War as any I've come across. Marlantes builds his narrative from the kind of mud-spattered detail that only a veteran of such an experience could bring: the drudgery and exhaustion of patrols, the tension that precedes contact with the enemy, the ever-simmering difficulties between white and black soldiers, good officers vs those who want to further their careers, the simultaneous horror and thrill of combat, the mixed pride and resentment over having been sent to fight, and the simple truth that the young men who fight are, in fact, young men.
If it took him 30 years to write this book, it shows in beautifully crafted passages (such as the jaw-dropping TS Eliot-inspired one at the end) and rich, suitably profane character dialogues that express the complexities of duty, race, fear, courage, and the inevitable chasm between those who have "been there" and those who haven't. As in many of the best books about war, it's clear that the author's experiences have been filtered through much examination. Why do young men kill other young men that they don't even know, in a conflict with unclear motives, over a hill that no one cares about? What is the meaning of this violence? If the answers to such questions lie beyond the edge of moral understanding, Marlantes attempts to pull the reader out to that edge, the place where oblivion negates all conventional logic, and "what matters" comes down to that thinnest layer of self that separates all human action from the indifferent violence of nature.
Is this a perfect book? No. Marlantes' choice to jump unpredictably between different character viewpoints probably would have worked better in a screenplay. Some of his scenes, for all the stirring insight in seemingly off-the-cuff conversations about race, religion, or sex, can't escape feeling intentionally placed to make such points.
Small complaints, though. Ranks with the finest war novels. Good narr, too.
I read the reviews and thought they were probably overstated. I was very wrong. This book is great and I highly recommend it. It rings with authenticity.
Retired CFO, Army wife, Mom of five, Grandma of six, two sons who served in combat, love to read books that reflect my values and faith, love mysteries, historical, military stories, and books that don't waste my time . . . if it doesn't have an ending that was worth the wait, I'm not a happy camper.
My husband and I listened to this audio book together on two long car trips. If you are offended by the language that soldiers and marines use, be forewarned, this book is full of it. At the same time, know that's how it really is and was. To think that God didn't walk with these brave men then or now in the heat of the battle, I believe is a wrong assumption. For God is surely with us all in the valley. The soldiers of Vietnam, for the most part were kids, just out of high school, naive, just out of boot camp, ready to be marines and win the war. Then they were dropped into a mess that no one ever could have prepared them for. My husband came into the army at the end of the Vietnam war, and thank God, and over his 22 year career never saw combat. Many of our friends were killed in Vietnam or had brothers who were killed or who came back completely changed after the war. This book is a book that every American needs to read or listen to. The truth about what politicians do when they send our young people to war is absolutely gut wrenching. And it continues to happen over and over, and the United States never seems to learn. I'm a mother of two soldiers who have served in Iraq. One of our boys is in Afghanistan right now. I am as patriotic and American as apple pie. But something has happened in America that is absolutely frightening. We don't know who the enemy is anymore.
My bachelor's degree is in History, and I love studying military history, but I was never much interested in the Vietnam War. And, while most of the books I've read dealing with war have been non-fiction, I have read a few war novels that I would consider "great." All Quiet on the Western Front, The Thin Red Line, and The Killer Angels are all books I believe to be great works of fiction based on real events and Matterhorn is on par with all of them.
The author is a Marine who served in Vietnam so the book's authenticity is unquestionable. I can't recommend this highly enough. The story and characters are rich and engaging and the narration by Bronson Pinchot is spot on. Do yourself a favor and pick it up.