I'm a John Green fan (The Fault of Our Stars is a must-listen title) and this book was recommended to me because of that. The book threw me headlong into the anguish and ecstasy of high school kids and the struggle to know who we are and how to be ourselves. The two Will Graysons, very different teenagers engaged in that struggle for identity, are excellent characters that I liked a lot and was also annoyed with occasionally. The book also does a great job of showing the highs and lows of love from the straight and gay perspectives. The readers did an excellent job of covering an eclectic collection of interesting characters.
Audiophile since the days I had to check 'em out on rickety cassette tapes at the local library. Currently working the other side of production as an author of romance and scifi/fantasy.
One of the best "reads" I've had in a while. Definitely amongst the best audio adaptations I've purchased. Moving, tender, comical, brutally honest, and brave writing. That's right... BRAVE. There needs be more works like this on the market. Plus, it was almost like this book was meant to be audio. It transitions perfectly to that medium. Had me laughing until it hurt, and hurting until I laughed. READ THIS. Or better yet.... LISTEN TO THIS N*O*W
This is a charming, engaging, and "real" story. I say real instead of realistic because some of the plot is quite improbable, but the characters are utterly convincing and lovable. Although the story is teen-centric, I appreciated that the minor characters of parents are portrayed as caring and understanding human beings and not as stereotypes or buffoons. Even the flamboyant Tiny Cooper, who is figuratively and literally larger than life, has a complex persona. The device which drives the story (and which forces the plot into its contortions) is that there are two very different Will Graysons, each written by a different author and voiced by a different reader, whose lives intersect at a time of mutual identity crisis. If I had to attribute my enjoyment of the story to one factor, it would be the respect with which the authors treat their characters and their very real teen struggles--with depression, loneliness, fame, purpose, and all kinds of love. A warning to the squeamish--the language can be quite candid and streetwise sometimes, but this is part of the verisimilitude.
Nick Podehl is probably my favorite narrator of all time. This is the eighth book I have that he narrates, and every single time, he does it perfectly. He has never disappointed me.
I've only listened to MacLeod Andrews in one other novel before, and while I loved him in Monsters of Men (also with Nick Podehl!) it was nothing like this. He narrates his Will Grayson with so much much expression in just the tiniest inflections. The whole time I was reading, I felt astoundingly connected to this depressed, adorable, vulnerable boy. (And as a side-note, however much they have paid his for this, it cannot be enough, because not only does he read Will Grayson astoundingly well, but he also SINGS. I don't mean that he sings a couple lines, I mean that he SINGS whole enormous musical numbers.)
Now, about the book: The story is great. It's fun. It's hilariously fun. It's full of large hilariously gay stories.
The first Will Grayson is the pretty much just the unwilling best friend on Tiny Cooper, the enormous and flamboyantly gay dancer/playwright/football player.
The second Will Grayson is a depressed, angry character, who hates everything in his life. There is only one thing in his life that makes him happy. He lives for those moments few and far between moments where he can finally be happy, even for a moment. As I said already, Andrews's narration is what truly *makes* this character.
If you are looking for a novel about being gay, this is it. If you're looking for a novel about a depressed, angry boy, this is it. If you're looking for a novel that will make you happy, this is it. If you're looking for a novel about musicals, this is it. I really do feel like this novel has something for everyone. Are there things that I would change? Sure. Parts I don't like? Yeah. But all in all, it is a fun story.
I am on a mission to listen to all of the Odyssey Award winning recordings. ("This annual award is given to the producer of the best audiobook produced for children and/or young adults, available in English in the United States.") The more I listen to audiobooks, the more I understand how important the reader and the production are to the whole experience.
This book definitely is an award-winning audiobook experience.
It is also a very important story for all teens, whether straight or gay. Tiny Cooper is truly a larger than life character, and the ways that both Will Graysons grow and change are realistic and heartening.
At ALA, Jamie from Bookmarked told me basically how much she loved David Levithan and John Green (and she was so bummed that John Green was sick and couldn’t come!). I knew who they were but I had never read anything that they’d written before. I fell head over heels for both of their writing styles (different as they might be) and I am so glad that Jamie introduced to me a side of YA that I don’t feel like I had really seen before.
John and David each have a character named Will Grayson and even though they share the same name, they are two very distinctive people. And they share a common friend – Tiny Cooper, whom I think I would both love and hate to have as a friend. Speaking of friends – that’s what this book is about. It’s about friendship and love and appreciation.
While most YA would be considered appropriate for ages 12-18 or even 14+, from my perspective, I think this book’s content is a little mature for a 14 or 15 year old. I’m not saying that the message isn’t a great one, but some of the content may be (depending on the reader, of course). I also come from a very conservative family and so my opinion might be a little skewed. Either way, the overall message that Will Grayson, Will Grayson sends is something that I think everyone can benefit from.
The narrators definitely brought the two Wills to life and embodied their characters.
This is a deep, insightful, painful, tragically real book that gives readers a rare glimpse into the world of not one but two very different, but somehow deeply connected, inter-related lives. The emotions, the feelings, the awkwardness, it all rings absolutely true and is amazingly transmitted through the narrators. The book takes what could have been a confusing mess and, by using two authors, turns it into a masterpiece performance that makes the story much more than the sum of it's pages. I love audiobooks but, usually, I know that I am sacrificing something of the story. Not in this case. The narrators make sure you know the point of view you are in, portray multiple voices well, and even read what could be a tedious writing device, IM screen names, with an accelerating pace that makes you feel what the characters must be feeling. I finished this book feeling like I had connected to not only the characters, but the vision of the writers in a very big way. This is the way audiobooks should be done.
I loved The Fault in Our Stars, but this felt too obvious and juvenile for adults. And yes, I know this is a YA novel, but I am writing this in counterpoint to the many adult reviewers who loved this book.
They did a fine job targeting YA...just not for adults
A cute, if unrealistic story about cute, angsty, unrealistic characters
In the great words of Tiny, of course. These are two of my favorite authors, so I was so excited to read this book by the both of them. This was amazing beyond words and the performance by the two narrators, MacLeod Andrews and Nick Podehl was one of the best if not the absolute best I have ever heard. Great job to everyone who took part in the making of this book!