Both versions are superb.
This is a unique feeling story in a Tolkien like world. It follows an honorable mercenary girl who ends up in a heroes story despite setbacks. It has a great system for military campaigns and war that is matched by a unique system of magic. If you like good authors and series like WOT or Magician (Feist), then this will be a purchase that you won't regret.
Lets see, I like Science Fiction, Fantasy and anything that lets me live another life for a little while; so immersion is key.
yes, the story was engaging, it kept me coming back for more and I stayed interested.
Maybe a sword fighting book that focuses more on action and militaristic styles of writhing.
I would have preferred a faster narration with more passion put into the voices, almost like they were the ones living the characters.
Not really it made me feel like I would any other day, it happens to be a little dry if you are not interested in a militaristic style of writing.
I was an okay book and I plan on getting the next one in the series just to see if she really sticks it to her dad.
I actually enjoyed listening to this to some degree, but it just didn't draw me in. I got another book I was eager to listen to and just stopped this one.
It's a kid's book, aimed at imparting morals, and describing the minutiae of a soldier's life, probably fun for a little girl who dreams of being a warrior or soldier.
Not very 'juicy' though.
When you listen to an audiobook and knit lace at the same time you will have to repeat both activities. I know this. I am resigned to it.The first time through the series the elves voices drove me crazy. If the reader had been present I might have hurt her. The second time through they didn't bother me nearly as much. And, to be fair, how does a human being reproduce a lilting, singing, nonhuman voice? I have no idea, and so I'm glad I didn't have the opportunity to hurt the reader.Final analysis - I loved the story, the perrformance was better than I would have said had I not messed up the lace pattern so badly. The lace was better the second time too.
No, both versions were very good. - I purchased this in addition to the The Deeds of Paksanarrion, omnibus edition, so I would have an option to listen to it as well as read it.
Yes, it may not be possible in all one sitting but I have no problem listening while doing other things and will find the time to finish it.
Great story and well told
A good read.
Paks, of course, because the development of the character shows just the right amount of detail, and makes you want to know what will happen to her.
Get the two other books, because you'll want to continue listening right away, I know I did.
The book itself is ok. It is the first of a three part series that is written as one book, in other words, you don't lose any time between books. I like that. When I read trilogies I like there to be a steady rise throughout the trilogy as a whole to a great climax at the end of the series. This trilogy delivers that. Each book gets better and better. Unfortunately, because of the single-book-split-into-three technique used here, I felt like the first one didn't have a very good story arc in and of itself. Maybe it is just my opinion. If you get through the first, the other two were good. I will note that the transition to book 2 might not make you want to read book 2. It doesn't give very many hints of what is coming so it almost feels like a separate story. Alternatively, if you get through book 2, you will want to have book 3 readily handy because it leaves you with a little bit of a cliffhanger.
Unfortunately, what I can't support is the narration of this particular audiobook. Jennifer Van Dyck just wasn't able to capture the protagonist properly at all. The story centers on the sheepfarmers daughter. Paks is 18 or 19 when she runs away from home and joins a mercenary company. Think with me for a second. A medieval-esqe/dungeons & dragons world, with a 19 year old girl (who is also incredibly naieve at first) in a mercenary company. Would you expect that to make her timid and indecisive? The whole first book the narrator makes her sound somehow timid and weak by using a more breathy tone than she does for some of the other characters. Most of the others were ok, but I just couldn't get around how weak, timid and indecisive way that Paks was read. I switched to the books for the second two and it made all the difference. In my head, she is strong and bold and she talks like it.
Just my two bits. Not saying you can't listen to the audiobook just fine, I just found myself constantly re-adjusting what I heard to what I thought it might actually be like, based on her actions, rather than the tone it was read in.
I have this series in paperback, have read it numerous times, so I do enjoy the story. The narrator is very distracting. As she reads the back ground, the descriptions she has a cadence that I had to check to make sure that the speed wasn't upped by accident. I've even attempted to take it down a notch so it sounds better. The problem with that is when she reads dialog she does so at a normal pace, which then throws off the adjusted speed of the recording. It's frustrating to the least. If this wasn't a series I know I like the story, I wouldn't continue and I certainly won't get a new to me series if she's narrating.
The Way Elizabeth Moon developed Paksenarrion and how Jennifer Van Dyck brought her to life. I have previously read this series and loved it, now I love it even more.
Paksenarrion of Course!!!
I havn't, but I'm gonna look for her now:)
This book is the begining of a wonderful journey, held me spellbound and made it hard for me to want to get anything else done.
Get this Book!
Sooner or later, it all gets real!
No fault of the narrator. Could only listen to the first part of the narration. The story never captures the attention and is incredibly slow. It suffers from not knowing if it is an adventure story or a misplaced romance novel with only one protagonist.