This is a remarkable book which describes how some insightful, influential and forward thinking Americans came to the aid of Britain during WWII. It also exposes those whose aim was to bring Britain to her knees by taking advantage of the precarious situation Britain was in to bankrupt her and set the stage for a post-war takeover of her trade. "Lend-lease" which meant that the US sold the UK old and decrepit ships for wickedly inflated prices and kept Britain poor following the war when the US helped Germany and Japan rebuild and left Britain starving was only finally repaid a few years ago; this was a deliberate policy of Americans who hated Britain and envied her pre-war status. The skulduggery and malicious intentions of the US are laid bare in this book, and serve to heighten and illuminate the goodwill and precious help that these three men gave to Britain. Had Britain capitulated to Germany as the French had done, with no place in Europe to base an opposition to the Nazis, America would have been in no position to fight them and would (with the delighted collaboration of people like Joe Kennedy, Charles Lindberg and other American heroes) have been forced to get into bed with Hitler. This book should be read by all Americans, especially Hollywood which likes to portray the Americans riding in heroically to save the day, and steals the stories of other nations' heroes with their historically incorrect portrayal of the Great Escape, the Enigma rescue etc., which were due to the British, Poles, etc.. Considering what an important figure in all this the American ambassador was (no! not THAT self-serving despicable person!) - the name of John Gilbert Winant ought to be better known. This good man was an essential element in winning the war and should be more famous. If Britain owes a debt of gratitude to anyone, it is to this man. A statue in London to John Gilbert Winant, anyone?
While there was some great historical information in the book I felt that it was quite a lot to slog through. I love history books and I love long history books, as long as they are well organized and engaging. This one took me 3 weeks to get through.
Had it been a biography of Winant, Harriman and Murrow, I think it would have been much more engaging but it veered off into many other directions. It's as if the author gathered much more research that she needed and was damned determined to fit it all in one book. It really needed some editing. Also, a good historical author should be able to leave her own political views out of historical text. She was completely unable to do that and I feel that it cheapened the value of the book overall.
It's not a horrible book and I learned a lot about all 3 of these men, but I don't think I could recommend it to anyone except a hard core history buff who has a lot of time and patience.
A transplanted Englishman, I spend my time on biography, history and military books. I appreciate good English and good narration.
Well written and thoroughly researched even if it suffers, as do so many historical works, from over exposition. Its three main characters, Harriman, Morrow and Linant, are brought into sharp focus with fascinating anecdotes and unabashed details of their private lives. I felt I could sit down to dinner with these three as if I knew them personally by the end of the book.
Inevitably, the book requires a deep context. Those who already know of the Churchill, Roosevelt and even Stalin relationships may find themselves re-reading; those who have read such experts as Ambrose and Keegan will not need the World War II historical episodes. However, the author relates such diversions to their diplomatic implications tightly and this distraction, if it occurs, will not irritate I suspect.
The reader is clear and relaxing as is needed for such a long treatise. However, as a small point...Lord Salisbury is "...Sauls-bury..."; Sandys is "...Sands..."; Cadogan is "...Kerr-DUGG-un..." I'll do you the favour of not trying to give you his pronunciation and even if Americans have a right to use their own language as they feel fit, proper names should be managed with respect.
I have edited 38 national best sellers and had a writing fellowship from the National Endowment for the Humanities.
If you like history, don't miss this book. It's one of the best I've read. It focuses on three influential Americans--Edward R. Murrow, Ambassador John Gilbert Winant, and Averell Harriman--in London in the years leading up the America's involvement in World War II and thereafter. They so empathized with the British and tried to get FDR unstuck, hoping he and Congress would realize the ramifications for the US if the Nazis defeated Britain.
I've read a lot about this period, but the book provides content I'd never seen before. I loved it.
Say something about yourself!
I've read all the acclaimed books, and many lesser known works, on WWII, and I thought I knew most, if not all, there was to know. I couldn't have been more wrong.
This book brought tears to my eyes and the reality of wartime London became more visceral than I could have imagined.
The book focuses on US Ambassador John Gilbert Winant, Edward R. Morrow and Averell Harriman. Their work, and their affairs with Winston Churchill's daughter and daughter-in-law (who was US Ambassador to France when she died) are covered in great detail explaining how they changed the course of history between our two peoples.
Something that I did not realize, until this book, was the extent of distrust and disinterest between the US and Great Britain before WWII. All in all, I am extremely happy to have read this book, I gained a great deal from the experience.
An old broad that enjoys books of all types. Would rather read than write reviews though. I know what I like, and won't be bothered by crap.
I thoroughly enjoyed the audio version thanks to Arthur Morey's narration. I consider it an excellent method of getting the story told accurately. I don't know if the print version could be any better than this.
The story of Gil Winant, of which I had never before even heard of this heroic man. Why do we not hear of such heroes? He was a real man who did wonderful things. He is my new hero!
Morey's performance is terrific! He tells this story with such emphasis on everything I never knew about WWll. His diction and empathy is spot on.
Three men who brought America into WWll for our greatest hour!
This book tells so much more than any history or war movie ever had.
I am so disappointed in the way the United States acted in WWll and the fact that we really have learned so little since than in our arrogance and ability to live as if we are the only people to win the war. I hope that some day we Americans will learn that we don't have to rule the world to have a place in it.
This is not the most tightly conceived, scholarly, or even original treatment of the period but it's a great listen and wonderfully read (except for the mispronounciation of KEYNES, as in John Maynard). For anyone interested looking as much for entertainment as enlightenment, I say you can't go wrong.
i was not quite an enamoured by this as some of the reviewers.
first, while the 3 leading characters flow in and out of the narrative throughout, this is not a book about them. This is a book about the alliance between england and the US. I agree with many other reviewers that, although i have read many books on this period of history, i have never had one that brings as much appreciation to this particular relationship between two countries. Its especially timely now, given the ongoing struggles to maintain unity amongst the democracies against common foes. And the three protagonists are all very compelling figures, as is the description of war time London/Europe, which really comes to life. While we think of the greatest generation here as a unique one. what they went through is nothing compared to the suffering in Europe.
The bad...I found to author's tone soporific. The book is a little morose, and perhaps the author is well suited, but at times i found my attention drifting. This is epsecially true in the middle. At this point I really felt the book was overrated, however, the ending is outstanding and really puts the entire period in perspective.
Overall I recommend this very highly, and I would have given it 5 stars if it were not a little bit of a struggle in the middle.
While I was familiar with Murrow and Harriman, I admit to having zero knowledge of who Gil Winant was. The book was worth the read just to learn about him but it taught much more than that. The author conveyed what it was like to be in London during WWII and conveyed political realities that do not appear in the "social studies" books.