If you are a fan of the show do yourself a favor and get these books. They give you the details the show does not have time to put in. It makes the show shine even more as you know the reasoning behind things that were left unclear in the show.
I'm a corporate training consultant and adjunct professor who loves to read! I'm always looking for the next big thing.
As this is the third book in the "A Song of Ice and Fire" series, I am finally beginning to get a good grasp on all of the characters, plot lines, and locations. It's taken me a while, but I felt much more comfortable with this book than I had with the previous two. Maybe it's because of my new comfort level with the series, but I have to say that I enjoyed this book much more than the previous two. It's a long book--to be sure--but it's definitely worth it.
The narrator, Roy Dotrice, is excellent. I don't know how he keeps all of those characters and their voices straight! His narration and his ability to distinguish all of the characters are two key reasons that I really enjoyed the book and was able to feel more at ease with everything that was going on.
I have a confession to make: The whole reason I am reading this series is because of the HBO television series. Let me clarify that just a bit... I read a review of the television series, and I thought I might like to read the books. I read the first two books in the series ("A Game of Thrones" and "A Clash of Kings") before I ever watched the HBO series. Having finished both of those two books, I decided to watch the first two seasons of the HBO series, which aligns with those two books. I loved the HBO series, and I was eager to read the third book before the third season came out. I still haven't watched the third season, but I've finished the third book. Part of the reason that I feel more comfortable with the books now, in my opinion, is that I have a much clearer visual idea of the characters, settings, and plot. While I'm glad that I waited to watch the first two seasons until having read the books, I am now glad that I watched them before reading the third book. I have a much greater appreciation of the books.
So, as for this book... Be warned. There is A LOT of action going on in this book. There are many surprises, twists, and complete shocks. It's very hard to review this book without giving too much away; however, if you've invested in the first two books, you will not be disappointed with the third.
Honestly this was the best fiction audiobook I have listened to. The story was incredible and the narration was perfect.
There are plenty of twists, turns, and "I can't believe that just happened" moments in this book. Masterfully written, this book is the beefy one of the series. I've listened to it twice now and enjoyed both thoroughly. The second time around you catch many of the nuances and minute details that truly make this book so incredible.
No one can narrate this series like Roy Dotrice. It is easy to lose yourself in the book as no characters feel forced and the voices for each are so unique that you know which character is speaking without the book having to reference it. At times it is hard to believe it is a single man doing the narration.
For those that have listened to or read the books, there are a few key events that I had to actually stop listening and take a few breaths! Intense and anxious moments abound here.
I did not really like the way the book was broken up. Chapters ending halfway through the audio "chapter" is a very annoying way to do it. I liked to listen to a chapter or two at night and the way the chapters were broken up made the End of Chapter sleep timer completely useless.
Easily the best book of the series, the best stories, Roy Dotrice is a master. After finishing this book and started on Book 4 i was in a mild depression, because book 4 is such a slog. Book 5 was a minor improvement, and I was again depressed when I ran out of Roy Dotrice to listen to. After nearly 200 hours of Roy I felt like he was an old friend.
I'm so glad I listened to my friends BEGGING me to listen to the audiobooks in my truck (I lack the time to read anymore)..
The Kingkiller Chronicles has a rather decent story line. I enjoyed it immensely.
47 hours goes by WAY faster than you want it to. Book 3 is a masterpiece.
Best ASOIAF book.
I find Roy Dotrice's vocal choices to be distracting rather than enhancing to the story.
I read the book quickly, and wanted to listen to it at work to refresh my memory. Unfortunately, I found the narration so distracting that I never could finish listening.
Wow, that is difficult. I think the character development and the core writing style. Mr. Martin takes the time to think how the character would see the action and within that character's chapters, he writes as them. I am thrilled by how he can make me hate what a character is doing and then show me the motivation. Also his plot twists are perfect. I read a lot and I normally can see a twist long before it happens. In the case of this series I get tugged along and am shocked and amazed by what happens.
I am impressed with how Mr. Martin has obviously researched history to develop a universe that is recognizable to us, but he can introduce fantasy characters and magic into the universe and it doesn't stand out as incongruent. We are nearly done with the fourth book and I'm very excited. We haven't watched the TV show, I think we'll hold off until we are done with the series so we don't get caught up in all the differences or "hollywood's" version of what everyone looks like.
I would definitely consider it better having both the ereader and the audio version. The audio version gives a more fluid feel to the story. Mostly because you don't have to struggle with the spelling of the characters names. For me, that can be distracting while reading. The audio version doesn't have this issue.
I am looking forward to finishing the series. Once you've gotten 100 hours into the series you kinda have to give it the benefit of finishing.
As usual, Roy Dotrice gives a great performance. He does a very good job of bringing characters to life. When the setting or scene changes, as a listener, you're disappointed for a few moments because Roy had set the stage and captured your interest.
Book three continues the story that the first two books began. Although there's not as much action as the first two books, I was not disappointed in the story and where it seems to be going. There's some really big surprises in store in book three. You'll be eager to start book four once you reach the end of the book.
Game of Thrones is an epic in every sense of the word. This world is so broad and immersive. You can tell that the author really spent a lot of time working out this story before he penned it. BUT this is almost to a fault, these books are so immersive you really do have a hard time trying to keep all the story lines straight. The overall story is worth the time, but if you commit to this series you're looking at around 160+ hours of audio.
The subplot of John Snow is my favorite part of the story.
There is no way you could do this even if you wanted to. At best I could do about 5 hours of it at a time.
I like G.o.T. and now having watched it on TV and hearing the books, I can say this fills in a lot. TheTV show really is great at picking out interesting parts of the story line, but they miss out on much the books fill in. If you enjoy the TV series and have A LOT of time to kill then these will make the universe more immersive. The Narrator does a great job at making voices for each of the characters. There are some story lines that are amazing and interesting. There are other ones that are long drawn out and at point dull. So you can take the good with the bad and decide for yourself.
What can i say, this was the Best book of the series so far, and the best performance as well. Roy does a great job of capturing the essence of each moment.
I would definitely suggest this book if they love stories with a while world of stories
Wheel of time series
He captivates you with his voice. How his voice changes for each character. Also the fact he reads every Song of Fire and Ice book is amazing.
There are enough moments where you either yell out with joy and pride. Then the next you just want to hold yourself and cry. But I think that's George R. R. Martin for you.
The book is very captivating and has a great flow to it as each character goes through their own trials and tribulations.