I was not happy when I started listening to Scot Sowers after loving John McDonough in the other books......BUT when I heard his portrayal of Peggy I got it. He did a beautiful Peggy and that is a large and important part of the book.
Home to Holly Springs disappoints me compared to other Mitford books. The story is not the caliber of the others. Maybe it is partly the interpretation of the narrator. He is skilled but doesn't fit Mitford. He made father Tim feel cool and more sure of himself and modern. I picture Father Tim as good, solid, always seeking to be led by God. Deeply respectful of humanity. But not cool in his retorts to others. I felt this was a different Father Tim. It was surprising to find that Matthew Kavanaugh had once been kind to a little black boy, though his father was brutal to him.
The whole story left me unsettled. We need another volume to connect us back to the Mitford world.
There were some very heavy parts in the story. It was hard to identify with father Tim all all of a sudden being a 5 to 13-year-old boy. Filled in some of the blanks that had been building in the other stories but was a little unbelievable in the outcomes.
No. I did not enjoy this book at all. I found that it was very boring. I so enjoyed the first series. It was a lively and entertaining read. Not so much with this one.
The Orphan Train. Unless I decide to listen to the original Midford stories again, I doubt I will pick up another Jan Karon.
Yes. I thought he did a nice job.
I didn't think it was. I didn't finish it.
I love these people and their lives. They share life changing stories while still sharing God's love in their lives.
I liked the way she weaved the story together, keeping the reader in suspense but so delightfully written you wouldn't want to skip ahead for fear of missing something.
I liked the age Pastor Tim is and the reflections he has on his life. I thought it is nice to think that we are never too old to learn something about our past that will explain things that we have never quite understood.
Love his voice, he just seems perfect for this book.
Yes, it made me smile most of the time, laughing out loud at other times.
I think this would make a wonderful movie!
One of my favorites as is the Mitford series. It continues to hold my interest after 7 books & fills in lots of answers
When Fr tim saved Peggy from being raped and tim telling his bro. He was a match 4 a kidney transplant both heart wrenching.
Peggy for all she endured and how she handled it
The entire series from "at home in Milford" through "In the company of strangers" will be my "go to" "feel good" books. Thisvis my 3rd time through and I still love them as much as the first time.
I am a mother of two adult children and married to a wonderful man. I am a full time Realtor who enjoys historical fiction.
I can't get past the story teller. This is nothing like the other books when John Mcdonnough told the story.
He doesn't continue the same characters from the other Jan Karon books.
The narration was excellent; voice interpretations were spot on.
The flashback moments into Father Tim's history were noticibly darker than anything found in the Mitford series. The change was necessary.
Scott Sowers was so brilliant a narrator I forgot he was one voice. I was especially impressed with his speech for a character described as having no teeth. It was so believable I hit rewind half a dozen times just to hear that character's first line again and again. He did an incredible job of selling Audible. I doubt my reading experience of this title, which I own in hard copy, would have had the same impact.