Finally got my hands on this book, though it was a much slower pace for me I thought it was a good story. It became a bit frustrating with the characters because time and time again important information was withheld. I also didn't like how Luce was portrayed more like a victim then a strong girl. She kept begging to be told of who she was and why she was sooooo important. I get why they wanted to shelter her from the truth but OMG!!! It was too frustrating. Overall this book was great the story was well written and the narrator did such a beautiful job voicing this story.

The narrator did an excellent job of expressing the characters' ages and emotions. The story was great, Lauren is a great author. I had already read the series and listening to it now, I still think it's a good novel.

My favorite sub-genre within YA romance is angels/demons and I love to see how authors put a new spin on an old tale. I was surprised by Kate's take on fallen angels, in a good way. The only reason this book didn't get 5 stars from me was because I didn't really care about the characters, except maybe Pen. I can't really put my finger on it. The writing was great, the story was cool, but something was missing. Had I not gotten 2-for-1 on Audible, I'm not sure I would have cared enough to get Torment, the second book.

I'm so glad I was recommended this series of books. I loved this first one, let's hope the rest as equally if not more satisfying!

Love love love this book! it was read really well and sucks you in right from the get go!

light reading and easy to slip into the book. the ending definitely made you run out to find the second book. quick read.

The story is so addictive, you won't want to stop listening! I have both the hard copy and audio book and I couldn't keep my nose out of it when I read it the first time nor could I stop listening to the audio book. The narrator is wonderful and really keeps you hooked. Can't wait for the movie and to start the second book!

Thank God this is a series. I'm looking forward to the rest of the books. This was a great book to listen to on my long trips in the car.

The narrator did a really good job telling the story with different voices for each character!

I wish I understood this book. It did not fill in the backstory or details like it should . But continued with the action scenes. I did not like the development of the story. It was too slow to start and did nit deliver in the end. The only nice part was the descriptions of the love felt between the two characters . Visually I could see them together in love at lake swimming or spooning or something. But i wish there was more story in the story rather than unexplained action.