I didn't do much for the first twenty years of my life, spent the next twenty in the military, and the twenty after that in college. Then, I mostly retired.
Some audio books require a period of time to catch the difference in the voices of the character. With these narrators, all the voices are similar, and I could not follow the story line even after an hour or more. Some books make for a really good read, some for a good listen, and some for both. Maybe this one would be a good read.
Well... I had downloaded this book some time ago, in spite of the bad reviews, and because of those reviews didn't listen to it for months. Now that I have listened to it, I feel silly for waiting. Perhaps the people who didn't like it hadn't listened to her other books? I thought it was great. I was totally into the characters and couldn't stop listening. Granted, I knew going in that it was a first part of two books and since I just finished it, the second part is already available and I am starting to listen to All Clear right away. I think Connie Willis is a great writer and I want to go back and listen to her other books again. If you liked Doomsday and To Say Nothing About the Dog, you will like this book too. Don't put too much stock into the bad reviews.
Throughly enjoyed the listen. The story captures and holds your attention and the narrator was great. Am jumping straight into All Clear.
Katherine Kellgren continually blew my socks off switching between men, women, boys, girls, many American and English accents. I was never confused about who was speaking. Simply amazing talent.
Plus the story was quite good too :).
I'm just not sure still if I liked this one or not. To say I was disappointed at the ending is an understatement, but at least I knew that going in. But dang. Slam bam and you better get the next book if you want to learn what happens. There is no reason why this book could not have stood on it's own - at least a little, with a continuing story. But hey, like I said I knew that going in.
It took me a bit to figure out what was going on here, I think partly because of the narrator. I'm not one for English accents so it took some getting used to for me. But an interesting plot started to develop and I got pulled in. Nothing overly complex and the author tells a good yarn, but, and this is a pretty big but, she does not know when to move on. Way to many mini crescendos that went no where. "He should be there at 9am, but he was not, but maybe at 4pm, nope not then either, well maybe tomorrow"....guess again. Gee I wonder why, let me analyze it, and analyze it again, and again and maybe one more time for good measure. A few times I almost screamed out my window. The title of the book might be better called "Beat a Dead Horse".
So why did I give it 3 stars then? Well that's the odd thing. There was a good story here and at times it moved along well and I enjoyed listening.
Enough to listen to the next book? Well that's the big question. I do want to hear what happens, but I just don't know if I can invent the time. The reviews lead me to believe I will again be frustrated. So for now I am taking a break to shake the cobwebs out of my head, but I think I will one day come back because as much as I hate to admit it. I liked the story and want to know how it ends.
So this review might not help you all that much, but it's pretty dang accurate - I think.
I am sure that a lot of people will enjoy this book. I found parts interesting and the reader very good. The story jumps about and gets bogged down in confusing detail. Listening to the book became an endurance event. I was relieved when it was over. It was a pity as the concept is great and the historical content very good.
It's got to be hard to write a dull novel about time travellers lost in the London blitz, but Willis has succeeded. There were so many ways this setup could have been made interesting, but I didn't hear any. I'm sure the narrator was trying her best, but she wasn't given much to work with. The characters were left undeveloped and the plot was nigh indetectible. Even though the first book stops in mid-stride, I'll pass on the sequel.
The premise of this book center around historians who have travelled back in time and are unable to return. What a great concept! To report on history with the perspective of someone who sees how it will affect the far future. Unfortunately the entire first book revolves around the characters trying to get back home. Not much character development or storyline. I was VERY disappointed and will not purchase the next book to see what happens. I already know what happens....NOTHING!
This is a good book. I'm fascinated by London during the Blitz so read everything--fiction or nonfiction--I can find about it. I also read Doomsday Book years ago (and bought a paperback recently to reread it) and was fascinated by the vision of historical research done by actually visiting the past. BUT this book leaves the reader totally up in the air. Clearly the situation is resolved in the follow-up book, All Clear, but novels need to have some internal integrity which this one does not, ending as it does--or not ending as it does. As it is, it reeks of the marketplace--how to ensure that the reader buys the second book. Even serial novels written for kids have more internal integrity in each novel. That said, I just put All Clear in my cart....
I like Connie Wilis books and this is no exception Luckily I read the reveiws that said it ends abruptly. So I consider this the first half of the whole book.