I enjoyed this novel much more than other Rutherfurd novels. Sometimes with longer audio books I tend to zone out and forget what's going on, but this one held my attention all the way through.
One of all time favorite Audible books. The story is fantastic, as entertaining for a history buff as it would be a person just looking for a good story. The narration is masterful, 36 hours and I never became bored, zoned out, or got the characters confused. That is in large part due to the excellent narration.
If you are a New Yorker, or love NY, this is a book you must read. If you are not a lover of New York, this book may turn you into one, it will in the very least give you an understanding of the history of place.
You root for the characters and through their triumphs, trials and tribulations you begin to understand what it means to be an American and a New Yorker. On a scale of 1 to 10 this book is a 10 for me.
I am a big fan of this genre and if you like this book you will also enjoy The Winds of War and War and Remembrance from Herman Wouk. The idea that you share the journey through accurate historic events vicariously through compelling fictitious figures is entertaining to me.
The father and son who stood on different sides of the American fight for independence were the two most enjoyable to me.
Yes and no. It's long and it gives you a lot to think about. It was enjoyable enough that I didn't want to turn it off.
Sweeping historical epic set in the greatest city in the world. I did not want it to end.
Absolutely. You're swept along with the incredible, fascinating, moving story of a few inter-connected families over several centuries and join them in experiencing the key historical events. You get to love the characters and want the best for them - very gripping, like Edward Rutherfurd's other novels.
When one of the female characters is wise enough to avert complete disaster in the Wall Street crash. I let out almost as big a sigh of relief as her husband would've done!
Read at just the right pace, brought that characters to life, easy to listen to.
A great read/listen. Very gripping and exciting.
It's better in the sense that I'd probably never get around to reading an 860 page book, but it's nice to have the book also to see the cool maps of New York.
the fate of the wampum belt
Hadn't heard Bramhall before....he did a great job...lots of different voices.
Dirk Van Dyke, as he felt so torn between his two lives.
It was a pleasure to listen to this audiobook....highly recommended.
This book made me look forward to my hour long commute to and from work! It was very entertaining; I loved the individual characters and the family tree chronologies that became characters in themselves. However, this book did take me several hours to really get into it - and I'm very glad I stayed with it because the book is now one of my favorites.
The book is very interesting I must admit, but how can such a historical novel (even though it's fiction) state that Grant won at Gettysburg???? I'm by no means a scholor of American history, but I do know that Meade won at Gettysburg. That aside, it's a great book. I know that sounded a little petty, but it bugged the Hell out of me when I heard it. I had to rewind to make sure I heard it correctly. Simple facts gotten wrong in such a good book shouldn't happen. It's still a great book. I'm 3/4 the way through and really love it. The timeline hops through decades without you realizing, so you need to pay attention or you can easily get lost. I still give it 5 stars!!
It is amazing that someone could cram so much history of NYC into one book and do it so expertly. I couldn't stop listening. It is well read as well as well written, which is pretty important given its length. The characters are wonderful. The story weaves its way through the lives of the main family and the ones surrounding them brilliantly. I learned more NY history reading this book than I ever learned in school, and I grew up in NY State. Thumbs up for this one from an avid audio book reader.
I suffered through the entire thing hoping that it would get better. Extremely boring characters that do not evoke any emotion at all. The history was interesting, but took a back seat to the dull characters. If you want the history of New York you are better off reading a history book. I can't fathom why this book is rated so highly. Would have given it zero stars had that been an option.
I've read and enjoyed every book Rutherfurd has written, this is one of the best! What an outstanding source for a movie.