very disappointed in this book. its presentation, before purchase, led me to think it would be a much more intimate, personal view of the various cases of missing wives that have been in the recent news. this was very misleading.
this book might perhaps satisfy a student looking for a textbook-type presentation of elements regarding missing wives cases. one could easily draw up an outline of these elements, highlighting facets where such cases were similar or dissimilar, etc., from the analysis this book gives.
however, if you are expecting some good old human interest that would REALLY illuminate your understanding of these obscenely ghoulish but seemingly rather common crimes, a delving more deeply into them than the popular reporting has provided, as i was expecting, prepare to be totally let down.
i soldiered on with the book, maybe halfway through it, expecting to, at some point, come to the real meat i was looking for, the ENLIGHTENMENT, before frustratedly giving up. it just was not there. the narration itself was perfectly ok. but this is NOT a book, it seems to me, that is going to make it to any bestseller list. it is DRY, DRY, DRY.
The GOOD: Fascinating subject. Interesting thesis. A number of cases are covered.
The BAD :Disorganized, redundant writing. Egregious misunderstanding/misuse of basic statistics. Questionable and erroneous conclusions, stated as fact. Author's bias leads her to present all men as one dimensional, which belies her personal agenda and causes her to lose any credibility, especially in her conclusions/analysis; Which is a shame, because she has an interesting thesis. Mediocre reading.
SUMMARY:Poor writing, forced reasoning and rushed, mistake-ridden reading spoil a book that had great potential.
I was able to listen to about 20 minutes of this before before I couldn't take it anymore - this narrator doesn't pause for punctuation which makes it impossible to follow - she sounds like the programs that are used to have your computer read text.
Another issue is that you hear the narrator taking a huge breath at the end of a sentence - which, of course, is because she rushes through a sentence without pausing for any sort of punctuation. Words and names being mispronounced, her rushing through each sentence without giving any sort of a break and having to listen to her suck in air at the end of each sentence is just unbearable for me. :(
The book, while very interesting, became a little jumbled at points when the narrator either paused with no punctuation, or split sentences into several thought instead of one coherent though.
This book is terrifying because it is real. No one thinks it could happen to them. This author shows it could happen to anyone! The book was a great read but the author kept repeating herself and it got a little tedious towards the end. If you like true crime I recommend it.
This is one of my favorites. I listened and then immediately listened again. I think at least one of the reviewers who rated this badly missed some key words such as "anomaly" when the author was describing traits of different 'erasers'. I listen constantly and to all genres. I found this book and reader to be excellent. Really a credit worthy read.
This was a very interesting take on wife-killers. It makes you wonder what other people may be thinking under the surface...is someone you know planning to do away with his or her spouse and get away with it? The most interesting aspect was the pregnancy aspect. Some men can't handle the responsibility of fatherhood, and that's when they kill their pregnant wives. It is also interesting how many of the "eraser killers" tell extensive lies about their success and status, kind of living a fantasy life until (usually) a pregnancy presents looming responsibility they can't handle. I would suggest more help from society for young parents, including more jobs. A society where no one has to feel quite so overwhelmed by the impending birth of a first child. In the case of Christian Longo, he was being shunned by his extended Jehovah's Witness family and I think that contributed to his feeling backed in a corner. If there were a working class level job where a man could go down and at least make an adequate living, maybe fewer fathers-to-be would panic and pull a Mark Hacking.
Now for another topic. (It won't let me start a new paragraph.) This narrator's inflection is terrible. She doesn't pause in the appropriate manner at the end of a section. The end of an entire section is the same as the end of a sentence, and both are too short. It was very hard to tell when a new whole section begins. Other narrators sometimes do this too, and it seems like the narrator isn't grasping the material enough to tell when a new section begins. Very annoying.
Long commutes=LOTS of listening. Thanks Audbile!
I liked the story line but HATED the narrator's voice. You can hear her mouth click due to dry mouth. A drink of water would help a long way!!!
Anyone else. Her voice is horrible and her mouth is dry and you can hear it.