Thoroughly enjoyable, well narrated, and fast paced with Likable characters. I look forward to the rest of the series.
This is a new series to me (though I've read Forstchen's "One Second After" and recommend it to anyone and everyone) -- and it was an entertaining listen.
As several other reviewers mentioned, the author's choice of adverbs is a bit limited and repetitious. If it had been written in software that has a word search, one could eliminate abut 75% of the uses of "evenly" and not lose a thing.
There are some other "oops" moments, as well, as Forstchen seems to forget occasionally that the protagonist has but one arm, and would have a bit of trouble leading a charge on horseback while brandishing a sabre or firing a weapon. There are several instances in which characters of different cultures and different languages have no trouble conversing without an interpreter... But the striking omission to me is the lack of attention to the feelings of the regiment over losing the link to ALL their loved ones in the "tunnel of light" event. The author devotes just a couple of paragraphs to this, which would have an overwhelming effect on everyone in the regiment.
Despite all that, Forstchen really knows how to write battle scenes, and keep them exciting and engaging. Lawlor's narration is fine once you get used to him, and I liked the listening experience well enough to order the next one in the series.
Complex study of human nature. One can't help but overlay this parallel world on our own. How many time are similar choices made (considered from a global perspective). Humanity is a state of mind. I'm hooked.
I liked the concept but it was poorly executed. At times the book was superb but mostly it seemed to be written for young adults. I may read more just to see if the author can do better.
I have found lately myself downloading and listening to books I read previously in paper format and this is one of them. It is a typical Forstchen book - well written with interesting characters and a compelling story. I enjoyed it as much in Audible format as I did in paper and the narrator did a great job.
But a word of warning - I had forgotten how difficult some parts of this book were to read (and are to listen to). I do not want to spoil the story for those who might be downloading the book, but the segments involving torture and some of the "dinner" scenes were just hard to listen to and I found myself skipping forward.
If you are not squeamish I think you would enjoy this book immensely. Having said that I only bought the first 2 volumes of this series in book format because I found parts too difficult to read. I would recommend it only for adults with a strong stomach, but recommend it highly for them.
Having read the entire series and then have the first book on audio is great. The historical accuracy of the regiment is fundamentally accurate - How they react to such an unknown threat such as it is, I believe is as humanly accurate as you can get. I enjoyed re-reading it and enjoyed listening to it. I look forward to the rest of the series to be added to this audio collection. If you like stepping outside the box, you will not be disappointed here.
Tried three times and just couldn't get into it. I can't figure out exactly what's wrong with it, but it doesn't work for me. It doesn't grab me. Never got past the first sections. Maybe it gets better, but I never got deep enough into the book to find out. Sorry.
I'm usually not one to complain, but I barely made it through this one. The plot and characters were underdeveloped and unimaginative, the narration was one-dimentional and strange (Over-Enunciated), and I thought worst of all was the author's dire need of a thesaurus. I'm all for onimonipia, but not everything on earth goes "snap". I'd pass this one up.
This is a bad attempt to meld SF and historical military fiction. It doesn't work at all. I try to finish the audiobooks I start, but couldn't do it with this one.