I am absolutely aghast at the edit of this audiobook. There are long pauses, two three seconds long, where we hear the narrator breathe through his nose or smack his lips. And this happens at least ONCE A MINUTE.
How did Audible let this sloppy sloppy edit get through?
THe narrator is fine, slow, but fine, but to hear him taking pauses and breathing makes this unlistenable with headphones.
After slogging through the first half of this book over the last 2 months, I gave up and moved along to something else. No fault of the narrator. I should have know better from McCullough's previous works. One primary source after another. Detail upon detail, minutia upon minutia. How is it possible to take such a profound story and reduce it to extended quotes about his son's penmanship? A story can reach a point (and this one did) where the detail simply overwelms the plotline. I found myself 15 hours into the story saying "OK, I understand what he thought. But why did he think this? What was his worldview? What motivated this philosophy? Who is this guy?". But all I had was an icon; another "empty suit" of a founding father. My fatal mistake was that I had previously read Ron Chernow's "Alexander Hamilton"; the antithesis of McCullough's style (and one of my Top 5 all-time reads). The first half of John Adams left me so bored I could not go on. So my 1-star rating can only apply to the first half of the book. I can only recall one previous time in my life when I found myself unable to complete a book. But I did feel a profound sense of relief when I finally "pulled the trigger" and walked away from this pointless and time-consuming pile of detail-flooded drivel. Sorry.
I would give five stars for the excellence of the research. Letters written by our founding fathers provide details perhaps not generally known today. For myself, I needed to fast foward through far too many parts, although this may speak for my own dislike of detail about the politics of the time. I wished for more personal details about the characters and more information about life during this exiting period of our history. I just got bored after the third section. I do recommend this book for those who like historical detail about "what happened when".
If you're expecting a good story, then look elsewhere!
Perhaps this author should take a lesson from Ken Follet on writing a history novel. This book is horrible; it reads like a high school textbook. It's all facts and very little story/plot. I tried to get into it, but no matter how many chances I gave the book, I gave up.
I gave up and read the book instead - which is excellent. The narrator sounds as if he has false teeth, and suffers from breathing problems and dry mouth. The long pauses, continuous smacks, and noisy breaths were very distracting.
Not too long ago I've read about Thomas Jefferson by Jon Meacham and that was an excellent biography. I was looking forward to reading "John Adams" because David McCullough has to be the best archivist in American History. The HBO miniseries about the second president of the United States is something to watch. Purchasing this book was an natural instinct for any history buff.
Here is my recommendation if you are thinking about getting this book, but recently read about Jefferson by the other author. Please do yourself a favor and wait to read about Adams. It is not because the story is not good and it is everything that you expect from McCullough, but the two biography mingles into one story, where you keep asking yourself that you already heard Jefferson's story before.
Don't read about John Adams if Thomas Jefferson is still fresh in your mind because it becomes a very long rerun on facts that you already knew from Jefferson's biography.
You should read one and then wait before starting the other.
I just gave this one 4 stars just because I kept asking myself, "Where I heard this information before?"
Obsessive reader, 6-10 books a week, chosen from Member reviews. Fact & fiction, subjects from the Tudors to Tookie, Harlem to Hiroshima, Huey Long to Huey Newton. In-depth fair reviews - from front to BLACK!!!
I was so entranced by the first 2 episodes of the HBO miniseries that I knew the book had to be even better. WRONG! The miniseries goes to the meat of the story, leaving the remaining 20 hours on the cutting room floor - where they belong. John Adams was not a great man, just a regular citizen who made great contributions to his country. He did like to hear himself talk and was narcissistic enough to think that everything he thought of or talked about was worth writing down. The author took advantage of the voluminous amount of written material left by the Adams family to try to make their lives worthy of the buckets of ink they went through. Even the narrator sounds like HE'S bored to death! This book is certainly not worth 2 credits or the "member's price" of $49. Don't get sucked in by the hype just because this is featured on HBO. If you got it for the promo price of 1 credit, consider yourself lucky. I urged you to watch it now on HBO, catching up on aired episodes via On Demand, or wait for the repeats. Actors Paul Giamatti and Laura Linney really breathe life into the roles of John and Abigail Adams. Finally, I was very offended by David McCullough's cavalier treatment about the news of Thomas Jefferson and his slave, Sally Hemings. With all of the documents at the author's disposal, I'd like to know what John and Abigail, both overtly anti-slavery throughout their lives, thought about a US President and one of the signers of the Declaration of Independence being outed as a child molester and rapist, who never even freed his "baby mama".
I've read several historical novels pertaining to American independence. This novel concentrates more on the personality of Mr. Adams and less on the historical events taking place. Perhaps this is because Mr. Adams left behind so many letters both from him and to him that the author got lost in the details. Maybe this gave Mr. McCullough so much material to work with that he lost sight of the importance of the historical events and the role Mr. Adams played in them.
The narrator is fair-a bit slow.
I am a big fan of historical fiction and even like reading true fiction if well written and read. I thought this book would be a natural choice for me so I picked it up. I was unable to get all the way thru the first part no matter how hard I tried. It was dull, drab and drawn out. Maybe if I had to write a report for school it may be worthwhile to listen to it. But as pure enjoyment it is a chore.