I read The Secret Life of Bees and thought it was a 5 star book. So I was excited to find Sue Monk Kidd's second novel. While I enjoyed the book, it was not as compelling as "Bees." In "Bees" every story line is woven into the fabric of the book. I found the Mermaid Chair a bit lacking in that department. There are too many holes and not enough back story to fill them. I was left with an incomplete picture of why characters behaved in the way they did. It was a good read, just not so compelling that I would make a point to recommend it to friends.
I was so excited when I heard about this book. I so thoroughly enjoyed The Secret Life of Bees and was expecting something on that calibre. It is not. It is a very trivial story with uninteresting characters and predictable plot twists. At times the story is sappy and almost always unbelievable. I could not relate to any of the characters or care about their lives.
I liked this book. I enjoyed it as much as I enjoyed The Secret Life of Bees. This is a book that was written to be read out loud. The narrator is quite good and you feel as if someone is seating across from you at your kitchen table and is telling you about an experience that changed her life.
I downloaded this book to "read" while at the gym, thinking it would make my dreaded exercise pass quickly -- what a mistake. I have only heard about 90 minutes and already regret buying it. The reader's voice slogs along slowly and, to my ear, annoyingly, so the book is dragging too. Maybe that's part of the problem, her slow pace. I wish I had read the readers' reviews more carefully before I got this book. I usually give books a longer try when I'm reading them, but listening to this boring reader and, so-far, boring tale is so painful that I am probably going to just bag it and get another book. What a disappointment after Secret Life of Bees. I recommend to anyone considering this book: read all the reviews and listen to the sample to make sure you can tolerate the reader's slow reading.
This was nice listen to, the reader had a nice southern accent. It was pleasant but not extremely moving. The plot was not indepth and seem to skim the surface of the story.
it was a very predictable story with stereotypes for characters. Middle aged housewife is bored and lusts after man of the cloth - nothing happens. duh.
The first half of the book was pretty good then it got sickningly sweet and stupid for a while before recovering some theme towards the end. Worth the sale price but not worth a monthly credit.
Monk's book "The Secret Life of Bees" was wonderful so I thought this one would be too.
Wrong! This one drags on forever, the author beats the reader (listener) do death with endles thoughts about trivia. If she wants to give us "the most important lesson in life" she needs to say it before putting us in a coma.
Like some other reviewers, I expected to like this book by the author of the Secret Life of Bees. I had also enjoyed her writings in Guideposts magazines for years. Mermaid Chair was awful. The lead character is shallow, self-involved and morally pitiful. She abandons her marriage for a monk "she loves" after meeting him once! The theology depicted is weak beyond words. The choice of narrator was equally poor.
Save your money and listen to All The Way Home or Nightfall.