My husband and I were listening to this as we drove through New Zealand on a recent vacation. Not even the beautiful scenery was enough to distract from the terrible acting of the character of the main dwarf (forgot the character's name). If you've ever seen the Fawlty Towers episode with the American who wants a Waldorf salad (absolutely hilarious) you'll be able to imagine the sound. I thought it might even be the same actor. Fine for the part of an obnoxious American, but not for a dwarf in Hobbit land. Just awful!
A lovely story wonderfully dramatized. I only wish it were an unabridged version of the book. There are a few places where the dramatization (lack of full narrative) make the story a bit difficult to follow (but only a bit).
Unfortunately, I find this rendition of the Dwarves' song tedious though in the story it is meant to be rousing. And on purely personal preference I can't get past the pronunciation of the Dragon's name. 'Smog' has never sounded right to me, though many claim it is the correct pronunciation.
Despite nitpickings, I would absolutely recommend this version of J.R.R. Tolkien's classic to anyone who enjoys being read to and likes a good story.
Tell us about yourself!
A must listen for you and your children. Fun, engaging, and wonderful theater of the mind.
I've seen or heard several renditions of Professor Tolkien's magnificent works and this one is, as I said, second only to the books themselves in more ways than I can count! The next best is the Rankin/Bass animated "Hobbit" and perhaps the Ralph Bakshee rendition of the first book and a half. I must say that the live-action movies take a poor third for the excessive liberties that were taken with the characters. The effort that Rankin/Bass made to complete Bakshee's work is utter trash! Thank heavens for "the Mind's Eye" who, I believe, first put these wonderful radio-plays on tape!
This is so horrible I don't know where to start.
Firstly the American accents are ridiculous - sorry but Tolkiens world is definitely based in Britain. The sound quality is terrible. The direction is ridiculous, the acting is worse than poor.
Do not waste your credits on this. Wait until a decent British actor reads the book.
The sound is not so great since it probably was made for AM radio. I couldn't understand the dwarfs song at the beginning of the story. The dramatization and the voices are good though. Its a nice summary of the story since it covers everything (I read it long ago). I still want an unabridged version.
I had a hard time understanding what the characters were saying with all the background noise of the dramatization.
I wanted to get an unabridged version of this book and series but it was not available at the time, now they are but disappointed I have to pay all over again for these books to hear them in that format.
The Narrator was good, it was the other characters that were hard to understand
None cut, but even out the extra background sounds so the voices could be understood more clearly.
We picked this book for a medium road trip, 45 minutes into the book was all we could take. The character voices were awful, sounded like 14 gents from Shady Shoals retirement home. To make it worse it sounded like it was mixed and recorded in a garage. Avoid this one like the plague