A good noir crime novel that pays tribute to the Hammett and Chandler tradition. However, it fails to convey a real sense of place and the narrator mispronounces German place names so badly that they are often almost unrecognizable which, of course, makes the characters speaking them unbelievable. John Lee does a very good job otherwise; couldn't he have been coached a little on this?
I really like the characters here, but the writing is a little to cliche noir, with too many similes. Not cliches in the characters or events, just in the writing style. Good atmosphere, good historical setting, good characters....I'll probably give Kerr another shot, to see if he tones down the cliches a little.
This writer can't seem to get through a sentence without at least one metaphor; usually more. It makes for impossible reading/listening. I gave up.
Excellent writing with great delivery. I can't want until next month to get the third edition. You will not be disappointed.
Historical Fiction at it's finest.
No, but I will be if he keeps on delivering this quality of work
I was eager to find a series which told suspenseful stories beautifully written about compelling characters in an historically accurate way. I love the work of Eric Ambler, and also enjoy Alan Furst, who in my mind is less consistently good. Philip Kerr's work came as a huge disappointment in every respect. The characters are so unlikeable I found it hard to care what happened in the story. The historical atmosphere created here is very thin; the language is vulgar, the story contrived. Ambler or Furst, this is not.
I am a fan of all of the Phillip Kerr books but the narration of this book was wrong. Bernie Gunthere is a tough Berlin cop, now private investigator, navigating his way through an increasing dangerous and insane Nazi environment. The narrator gives Bernie an english accent which makes him sound like a Duke or Earl and not the gritty character we have come to know. The story is great but I could not get to the reality of the story because of the wrong notes of the narration.
this was a noir detective yarn, set in pre-war Germany. I was hoping for something like Alan Furst, but on the contrary, the characters were cutouts, the villains predictable, and the narration cringeworthy. Gratuitous violence, too.
Enjoy listening to audible books just before going to bed. This one kept me up until wee hours of night. Really exiting and great understanding of Nazi Germany in 1930s. Will certainly buy the remaining 3 books.
I love books in the detective novel genre, and really enjoy stories written about the WWII era. This one takes place in pre-WWII Nazi Germany and introduces the protagonist Bernie Gunther as an Ex Cop, "Good Guy" detective.
Overall the story is a little flat and predictable, but the fictional tale around actual historical characters is interesting from a lot of angles. I like the author's writing style and his candid depiction of the real life brutality and violence that existed in 1936 Berlin, and I do look forward to continuing the series.
The narrator John Lee is one of the best in the business and is terrific in this one!
Overall Recommended, especially if you like the genre and stories about this era.
Love a good read/listen!
Yes; I'm a Kerr/Gunther nut...read them all and am now working through the audio books in order. I will probably reread March Violets and then listen to it again. John Lee just nails the flavor of Gunther and his view of Germany under a rising star:Hitler.
Bernie Gunter because he reminds us that no one is a saint, but we all can have moments when we stand our ground.
I have listened to some later Kerr/Gunteher readings by John Lee. His performance is consistently brilliant but this book brings out his best.
I gotcha ya Sieg Heil right here!