I read this book on recommendation of a good friend. Due to a post traumatic stress injury I had to take time off from my usual genre of crime thrillers. I haven't read fantasy genre since HS in 1980/84 (The Hobbit). The book is divided into parts which is four stories within the story. I like that usually, and did like it here, but there are so many characters that I wish I had kept notes or printed out a copy of the character list.
Several reviewers have commented that they find it unbelievable that the five main characters could so easily accept their part in the beginning of the story. After starting the book over to re-read, I can see how some experiences of some of the five could have led the others to believe or want to believe.
I have no complaints about the writing or the audiobook as I switched back and forth between the two. I did slow the speed on the audiobook to .75 so that I could absorb words and names that I am unfamiliar with. It made the book longer while listening, but improved my attention and comprehension of an unfamiliar genre.
My one and only complaint is of the character Jennifer's storyline in this book which I am told is necessary to the trilogy. I will hope that is true since her story is the main story that brought me to tears. I recommend this book completely and I recommend the audiobook as well, since pronunciations of words found in this genre are different than in other genres, but was so enjoyable. I ended the book one day and the next started it over so I can have the characters and places engrained in my head before continuing the trilogy.
This series never gets old - I've listened to it (and read it) many times. The narrator is great - never distracts and pulls you out of that other world. If you are looking for a story that is high and grand and will speak to your soul, this is it.
More interesting characters and better story development.
I'd have to sample it first.
Simon Vance is the reason I chose this book. He did what he could with what he had before him.
Old Bear likes the honey
The book is very well written. Kay is a fantastic wordsmith. There are bits of the tale that are slow however and I found myself distracted from the narrative at times.
There are a number of well written characters in this story. I have difficulty picking a favorite.
For the most part.
Of course it does. It ends on a virtual cliffhanger.
I prefer the story and narration of Tigana, but if this is Kay's first book, he could have done much worse!
I had just finished reading The Lions of Al Rassan by this same author and absolutely loved it, so I was excited to try another of his books and thought to start at the beginning of his writing journey. Mistake. This is an author showing much less maturity and style. There are occasional moments that are compelling, but not enough to sustain my interest in his theme.
i read this series many, MANY years ago and it always remained among my favorites. The audio book narrator is talented and adds a certain charm of his own to the story.
Great tolkien-derrived fantasy world with a modern twist. Great characters and plot. Only gripe is the Canadian accents which you get used to. But other than that Simon Vance is my favorite voice actor to date!
I liked this series more than I initially expected. The literary device at the beginning to bring the charterers from"our" world to the alternative fantasy world was a little clunky. And lets face the world building without JRR Tolkien would not have happened, The dwarves and the characters who were in effect the Elves, even to some of the details was not quite copy and paste but pretty darn close. But what fantasy, especially high adventure fantasy doesn't owe Tolkien? Some are more inclined to use it for inspiration while others need to mine Middle Earth a tad more specifically. As a story I liked the characters, they developed as the story progressed, I cared what happened to them and the magic was cool. That seems to be a good way to spend 40 hours of audio time.. I like the longer stories and I would recommend this one.
Great story with all the richness and depth one expects from Guy Gavriel Kay's work. However, I found this one quite difficult to follow. So much so that I repeatedly lost the plot entirely if my attention was diverted in the slightest. I'm an enormous fan of Simon Vance, yet he seemed to struggle with the "North American" accent, leaving some dialogue a tad wooden. Neither were deal breakers by any means, but listeners should be prepared to experience something that requires a bit more patience than anticipated from this particular collaboration.