Probably based on a true story and starts OK, but it gets increasingly profane and the author gets very self absorbed trying to pose as a tough M* F* from hell. Also a number of technical errors like 'Author lighting a thermite grenade and white phosphorous dripping out.." - This makes me believe that the co-author has had a very heavy influence, dramatizing the book.
A good idea and storyline spoiled by profanity, obsession with gore and dramatizing.
Yes I would. One of the top non-fictional war books (audio) I've read.
No, it was spread between several days
Two? Yes Two. I recently read this account of the taking of Fallujah and some months back I read " No True Glory". Since they both deal with the same event in this war I thought it only fair to make a short comparision. With this book my main complaint was the narrarator. The pitch of his voice was just not appealing to my ears and his delievery at times was harsh and rapid. A good narrator gives his listener time to fully understand what he has just said! As for as the stories both are good. Both books are well written. Having said all that, In my opnion are far as description and depth of feeling No True Glory would have to come in #1
Everybody should listen to this book before deciding on how they feel about the war on terror.
Beginning to End
David Bellavia for Congress!!!!
Whatever your feelings about the war in Iraq, you will find this book compelling, horrible, heartbreaking, and uplifting, all at once. Bellavia is (seemingly) completely honest, utterly introspective and self aware, and, it turns out, a damn fine writer. The narrative is, for the most part, tight and taught; the book well edited. Porter does a fantastic job narrating this book. I recommend it to everyone, conservative and liberal alike.
In the Top Ten War Stories!
The Solider involed in the Hand to Hand fight to the Death!
Any Good Narrator would have been good with that material!
Just to know what it was like to see a man die by your own hand up close and personal!
It just was another GREAT Book about the latest War of America and How it affects the Young Men we send to fight and die in it!
I have listened to this audio book two times and I will likely listen again. Ray Porter provides an EXCELLENT read for a book filled with suspense, tension and emotion. Staff Sergeant David Bellavia is truly an American hero!
This is a superb book about Iraq and the narrator is the best reader I have heard on audible so far. Very vivid and engaging story. Incredibly well written.
This was a fantastic book. Combined with Michael Ware's work and Yuri's photographs you get a very real look at the work being done by our soldiers abroad. Door by door you live with SSG Bellavia and his crew as they fight through Fellujah. If you want to hear a soldier's unfiltered point of view this is a great read.
Clearly, most Audible listeners would enjoy it more as the book got good reviews.
Much of the book is dialog on speed; constantly frantic; very difficult to listen to. I have to accept that people spoke like this in the Iraq deployment since I wasn't there. To me, it sounds like the ravings of adolescents who have overdosed on steroids. I was not at all persuaded that this is the bearing of a skilled and professional soldier. Given that the US infantry was outfitted with night vision glasses, multiparty communications, and the most modern weapons systems, it appears they made a lot of mistakes; perhaps some due to raging egos. The sergeant constantly demonstrated an 'attitude' towards officers. He sounded downright insubordinate. In his own descriptions he appears mentally unstable. Again, I wasn't there, but it seems unlikely that the results would warrant keeping a person like this in a sensitive position in the military (fighting house-to-house).
The book seems to assume that readers would agree that Iraq was a just war fought for the Iraqis. The writer appears committed to the importance of the the US involvement in Iraq, but there should be at least some mention of the widely held belief that the war was sparked by government claims of WMDs.
By the time I reached the end of the book (the epilogue is interminable), I wanted to wash my hands to cleanse myself of the awful way in which this man treated his family. If you are a fan of intelligent non-fiction about war, try William Shirer, Rick Atkinson, or Cornelius Ryan, not this poorly written book which sounds like an action movie without video.