I am brutally honest. Popular, love everything they read, reviewers are scared to go neg. and risk their ranking. It's your money!!!
The Science Fiction Book Club pick this as one of there favorite books written in the 50's. When I read it years ago I loved it and so when it went on sale I bought it. I must mention here that this audio club has the greatest sales.
This is so much different then most of what Clarke writes. Fantasy readers would not recognize it as fantasy, but in comparison to most of Clarke's hard Sci-Fi this could be a fantasy. One reason for that is that it takes place billions of years in the future and unlike what most writers do, he does not knock man back into cave man days.
The main character is unique and does not fit into the society he lives in. He does not give into peer pressure and he stays unique. This will appeal to anyone who has ever felt different. Though some see this as a depressing novel, I feel that the spot light on unique people who are willing to challenge the system as very uplifting.
Isolationism and not wanting to leave our comfort zone is a big part of the book.
Parts of the book sound like something Robert Reed would write about today, the Grand View and great lengths of time involved.
This has several narrators and music, which I thought at first would lead to a great experience. I think that they would have done better with one talented narrator instead of several not so talented narrators and though the music did not detract, I do not felt it added anything.
Other really good AC books are: Rendezvous with Rama, 2001: Space Odyssey, 2010 Odyssey II, and any short story collections.
This was one of the first science fiction novels I'd ever read ever so many years back. For that reason it was the first Audible book I downloaded. It was and remains a favorite. Some have said it is not one of Clarke's best, but I tend to disagree. Perhaps that's just the memories bound up around the story, but there you go.
I enjoyed the sense of discovery as Alvin explored his universe; first the outskirts of Diaspar, then Lys, then the stars. The sense of physical exploration and discovery of new landscapes is something I miss in more recent works.
The performance was mildly uneven. The different voices were obviously recorded at different times, using different equipment, different EQ settings and different levels of compression. This created a slightly uneven flow to the dialog, something which could have been avoided by bringing the voice actors in to record at the same time.
No. I used it to pass the time on a long daily commute. It lasted better than a week and served its purpose well in keeping me entertained in traffic.
I first read this book, I think as a novella, about 30 or more years ago. It's been in my wishlist for quite a while because I could still remember the story pretty well. I liked it then, but I loved this version. Not just because it is an audiobook, although that helps, but because I appreciated the story a lot more, or maybe I just absorbed the nuances better.
This is a definite must for anyone who loves the theme of exploring ancient cities and rediscovering lost worlds.
The narrator was excellent. Once you're into it, the character voices click and you can't imagine any other voices.
The City and the Stars is a classic for a reason and not just because Arthur C. Clarke is the author, so instead I will write specifically about the audiobook.
This reading is almost a dramatisation since the individual characters are all ready by different narrators and there are musical backgrounds. Unfortunately this isn't what I expected given the listing on audible.com. Perhaps in this case I cannot provide an accurate review since dramatisations/multiple narrators really aren't what I enjoy listening to. I prefer my audiobooks narrated by one person who can add their individual drama to the reading.
The quality of the recording is very high and the production values are wonderful, but since there is no indication in the description or sound clip of exactly how the book is presented I must rate it low since it's not actually what I expected or wanted when I purchased it.
Clarke has written far better, but the big problem is the absolutely awful narration. Both problems together mean that unless you're reading Clarke and trying to complete the set, you should avoid this one.
One of Arthur C. Clarke's earlier works, I loved this story 25 years ago, and it still holds up these many years later. Sadly, the narration team was one of the worst I've ever heard - and I've been an Audible member for years. While the person doing the Main Character was ok (not great, but ok) most of the others seemed like they were reading an unfamiliar script, There was very little (if any) emotion conveyed by the readers and I found myself literally yawning while listening. NOT a good sign.
Alvin's adventure is all one fine adventure - to relate any of the many excellent moments would be to reveal spoiler after spoiler, something I won't do. For those who can handle a monotone narration and simply enjoy the story, I highly recommend this.
Monotonous, emotion free, pedantic reading simply couldn't do justice to the excellent story. With one of the many outstanding readers that Audible's productions normallly have, this would have been an incredible success.
The City and the Stars makes you think in many ways, challenges you to set aside the all to common "glory days, war across the stars, humanity ascendant" sci-fi stories that dominate the genre. There's a lot of philosophical areas to ponder...if you can just get past the horrid narration.
Would definitely recommend it; especially to people with an interest in philosophy and/or (of course) science fiction.
It is somewhat comparable to "The Moon Is A Harsh Mistress" by R. Heinlein; since it gives a very realistic image of a fictional future in which humanity, or a part of it, strives for something greater than its (then) current setting and situation.
One of my many favorite scenes (be warned for plot spoilers !!) was when Alvin decided to leave earth for the first time, using the spaceship he found. Apart from the fact that this is one of the key turning points in the book, it also captures very much the ambition of Alvin as well as one of the central thoughts behind the story; finally, after years of isolation, the human race sets to explore the universe once again.
Exploring the past, to find a long lost future purpose.
This book has definitely entered my top 5 favourite books of all time !!
This version City and the Stars is more on the order of a radio drama than a typical Audible book. I thought this presentation was effective, but as a story it's not one of Clarke's best works, which range from hard science to near fantasy. This one is toward the fantasy end of the spectrum.
I loved the story but found the production of the audiobook rather annoying. Some characters' voices are so distorted they are difficult to understand. Other times there are huge discrepancies in volume between narration and dialogue, which makes it bothersome to listen to with headphones. There is also frequent background noise and music which I find incredibly distracting. If these issues don't bother you, give this a listen; otherwise, it might be better to seek out a different production or read the text version.
It was good to find a work of the old masters that I had not read. The supreme story and incredible full cast performance make me recommend this above most anything else you can get. It will be hard for me to go back to more modern and less accomplished authors and then Clark. It is great adventure and like most Clark deals with the great existential questions of life. If you like that kind of thing you can't do better than this. There is no great romance or love affair, or space battle, no villain who needs to be concocted to create drama. Instead we have an incredible civilization, fully imagined and entirely reasonable though completely alien. Enjoy.