After "Good to Great", "Built to Last", and "Great by Choice" I had some high standards. Those books were worth reading and packed full of research. First, I don't know if "How the Mighty Fall" has stood the test of time in its conclusions. Second, this book seemed like something thrown together in a weekend. I wish I hadn't wasted my time.
Another great bit of research by Jim Collins and his team and very well presented using Jims' usual style of analogies and metaphors.
However, it is not up to the standards of Good to Great or Great by Choice. I've listened to his books in the wrong order and there is a deal of repetition from Good to Great and obviously Jim was deep into research data for Great by Choice when this was written.
Despite being the weakest book, it is still a great listen. You simply have to
love the work this guy does and his narration is full of energy and enthusiasm as usual.
Because of the repetition and this not being as good as his other books and the relatively steep price tag, I gave the story a 4 star rating instead of 5.
Overall this was a good book and great to listen to. Narration was great and story line examples were interesting. it passed the time but was nothing close to "Great by Choice" which was in my opinion a much greater book.
I'm a seasoned leader and strategist. I'm an expert in communication, sales and marketing, customer service and training.
I first read, then later listened to this book many years ago. This is a book that I have come back to several times, largely to find a paragraph to share with someone. There are times that I come back to re-read / litem to the book again to review where I see us being, and if there are danger signs on the horizon. A great read, from a wonderful author - a must for any leader!
I thought this was an excellent book on leadership and business strategy. As a business owner myself for almost 25 years, I have seen how a company can find themselves in the various stages of decline if they are not careful.
Even our company went through some precarious times as we went through an “expansion mode and business model change” right at the beginning of the recession in the mid-2000’s.
That was a time when financing was easy and banks we almost “giving” money away to almost anyone who asked. I got caught holding the bag as the personal guarantor on the business loans and then started taking the pro-active steps to right “the ship”, downsize, cut overhead and get back to focusing on what we do well. Just in the nick of time!
Collins’s book points out some straight-forward approaches and steps that business owners and leader can/should be aware of and take in order to keep their businesses running well and profitable/successfully.
Great book for all!
Long and tedious excuses on previous book. Not sure if extrapolating inferences from a handful number of examples should be considered a scientific or systematic approach. Should definitely have hired a professional narrator. Although I had long admiration for the author, his tone did not come across as enjoyable for audio books.
Tell us about yourself! I commute looooong distances each day and absolutely devour audiobooks. Audible has made the many hours in the car enjoyable! I really like their customer "reviews" (very helpful) and their no-questions-asked return policy - really, why do some great authors think they can also be great narrators?!. Can't wait for my next monthly credit to drop :) If you love audiobooks, then audible is for you!
Get a different narrator...with few exceptions, you know you're in trouble when the author decides to read his own book (Bill Bryson is a notable exception)
No characters portrayed.
Hire a professional reader/narrator
Anyone interested in business
Jim Collins has written an excellent book (as with his others)....but he cannot narrate. Terrible overacting.
Having not reviewed the print edition, I cannot comment. Having said that, Collins does a very nice job of describing details from the print edition, to orient the listener to the point or lesson he's trying to convey. As with his other audio books, he does a great job delivering the message.
I enjoyed his discussion of HP and their fall; unfortunately, their story is all too familiar - a company in search of a savior with no clear strategy to pursue.
With many of his books, it's good to listen, reflect, then listen more.
Another outstanding book; he puts this recession into some perspective and does well detailing the steps toward total and utter failure. The message from this book could be used to describe why government administrations falter, once great football teams become losers, and similar applications.