I had heard lots of good things about this, so
i gave it a try. Uggh. Couldn't get through it. Painful to listen to. Go see the play.
The person who could take the time to warm up to this book, is someone who has some serious time to pass. The writing is very detailed and descriptive, but it does this at the sacrifice of keeping any reasonable (for me) pace of story. I got bored and dropped it a third of the way.
Perhaps a second issue is that the very popular play which is based on this book is so very different in tone, tempo, detail and where it picks up the story, that the book won't work for your kids who have seen the play and want more of the same. In fact, the book is an adult experience to the point that I would say that it's R rated.
On the whole, it was an enjoyable listen. The narrator was quite good. Definitely not for the kids, though! This is a very adult fantasy.
The story itself was intriguing, but dragged. It took far longer to develop than it should have. There were several segments, such as the scene in the Philosphers' Club, that ate up time but really didn't add anything of value to the plotline!
Elfaba, our heroine(?), is a gutsy, like-her-in-spite-of-herself underdog who refuses to be walked on. She helps Glinda, a spoiled rich girl, develop a heart and a conscience.
Usually, I go for the unabridged versions, but, as an audiobook, Wicked would be more enjoyable abridged!
You are definately not in Kansas anymore. This is a totally enjoyable listen right down to the story tellers voice. The charachters are vividly brought to life. As a child The Wicked Witch of The West scared me, today is a different story!
I hated the Wizard of Oz movie, but growing up we had to watch every time it was on because it was my sister's favorite movie. So I saw listening to this book as a kind of personal revenge. After reading the reviews, I wasn't expecting to like this as much as I did. And I really liked this book. In fact,I kept hoping she survived the bucket of water.
First of all, I loved the Oz series as a kid and I appreciate this excellent and imaginative story. I am sure Baum would approve. However, I think it is for serious fans only. If you did not read "The Patchwork Girl of Oz," do not get this book. But if you are a lifelong fan of Oz, then you are in for a real treat. Also, the narration is top-notch.
After the first five and a half hours of listening, all one can think of is, "How will I ever get through the next 13 hours." The story just keeps dragging on and on with no action or story development.
If you listen to the sample, which is the forward in the book, it sounds like a real interesting story. Unfortunently the story slowly begins before conception of the witch, and is entirely too focused on the mondane of her life.
If there is an abridged version that gets to the important story plots and action, I would recommend that. Get the unabridged to help with insomnia.
The story of Dorothy, her friends in Oz, and the Wizard have entered our collective consciousness and we sometimes see only a children's tale. This book presents a new view point: Oz seen by the Wicked Witch of West as she is born and grows to womanhood. The trials of one who is different and yet has the same feelings we do. The elements we know from Baum are present, but seen in a green tinted glass, distorted, and sometimes making more sense. I enjoyed this book very much and I highly recommend it.
Middle School teacher with a 100 miles round-trip daily commute; which I could never maintain all these long years without audible books.
Lovely piece for my hideous 3 hour daily commute. I enjoyed this creative Wizard of Oz prequel. Tilted a tad tongue-in-cheek, "Wicked" reveals at once familiar and nostalgic background bios on The Wicked Witch of the West, Glenda The Good Witch of the North, and Nessa-Rose, The Bad Witch of the East. It definitely lightened up my days.
I read this book a couple of years ago and loved it. Now that I'm commuting I thought it would be a good listen, but I found it rather tedious. Sometimes I found my mind wandering. I remember thinking it was hard to read, and I guess I rushed through the parts I found slow and relished the others.
The narrator was very nice to listen to. I am now listening to "Son of Witch" and the author recorded the narration, which is disappointing. He's a much better writer than reader.
I have to say, though, that this is one of the most clever books I've read and heard. And I think it's too bad they didn't follow more of the story in the musical. Maybe a movie?