I am waiting patiently for the best book on earth!!
I loved this book~ The history and story combined make for a delightful read!
Of course Mary and her poor hands!
This book is excellent. If you like an epic tale of struggle, misfortune and meager survival then this book is for you.
However, this book is also brutal, bloody and full of graphic descriptions of horrific child abuse. If you are sqeamish, don't try this.
Good reader, gets into the characters
An O.K. story, but I've read better about immigration to down under
Say something about yourself!
I almost gave up after an hour or so of listening but pushed on. Glad I did. Found the plot a bit weak book but enjoyable nonetheless.
Hawaii and Papillion - the excitement of a new beginning in Hawaii with the misery of prison as described in Papillion.
Mary - her perseverance was amazing; hard to think of another character similar.
I could suggest any number of clichés, but "Misery" needs to be included in any other title.
This was a great book. I found it very interesting that the author, Bryce Courtenay, has created much of the on-line related documentation tied to the English prison ships. He did a great job of researching the facts surrounding this topic.
Avid reader through college now with no time to read. Audiobooks saved my life!
I gave this book 5 stars but really based on this volume alone, it may be more like 4 stars but taken as the foundation of a fantastic (so far... 3/4 through the 3rd book now) series, it's bumped up a bit.
The story does start out slow. I'm not gonna lie that I had to ask my buddy who had read it already if it was going to pick up and he said yep, and he was right. The biggest problem is not really the pace but how little I liked or cared for a couple of the main characters. It wasn't until the end of this book and some way into the next that the reasons for what seemed like a very drawn out character development became clear.
Just know that the author is using his characters not only to advance a great plot but also to tell some facts/history about the times and place they lived so we're seemingly not meant to love them all.
Also, the one real criticism I have of the series as a whole and somewhat of this book is that at times the author chooses to "wrap up" certain parts of the plot without really letting the story play out. We hear about "the rest of the story" through a conversation between characters or a letter read aloud. Sometimes I found myself really wanting to have stuck with a certain character or part of the story because it was interesting only to be taken into the future (this is an EPIC story spanning generations so it does skip forward from time to time) and left hanging about what actually happened.
That said, I HIGHLY recommend this book and this series. This genre is not in my usual wheelhouse either so it was surprising to have loved it as much as I did/do.
Brilliant, but too cruel: The book is a wonderful piece of literature worthy of the sweep and wildness of Oz and the griminess of Dickens' London. The narration of the audiobook is the best I've heard. The genius of Humphrey Bower's voice even exceeds Bryce Courtenay's as a writer. Bower does innumerable voices outstandingly well, from little snot-nosed urchins to aging whores and pompous magistrates.
Courtney has created a wonderful tale from the skeleton of history known about the 19th Century rascal Ikey Soloman (deemed to be Charles Dickens inspiration for Fagin in "Oliver Twist"). The fictional character of Mary Abacus is just as interesting, if not quite as endearing. And the secondary characters are wonderful in their scruffiness, pomposity, and winsomeness.
The book has one minor, and one major flaw, in my view. The minor is that conclusory statements about Ikey and Mary are made several times, which turn out not to be true. The one most common is that "Ikey is a broken man" or "has lost his will". But then he lives on to commit another scam or mentor another little scamp. But again, it's a minor quibble. More troubling is Courtenay's horrifying tortures of Mary. He goes much further than is necessary to win our sympathy and show Mary to be indomitable The brutality inflicted upon her in at least three instances is at The Walking Dead level, over the top and gratuitous. Bear the pain, the book is otherwise a delightful experience.
Very good and solid story that will keep you hook till the end. And most of all OUTSTANDING performance from Humphrey Bower. He gives so much lives to the different characters
I am going for book #2!!
Engaging, well narrated.
The narration of this audiobook is outstanding. Mr Bower's portrayal of the characters, especially Ikey Soloman, made the story feel real.
I was fascinated by this tale of clever and ingenious people who, by default of their birth into the lower classes of English society, are destined to make their living by devious and criminal means. You can't help but admire their industriousness and ability to make the system work for them, in spite of the danger of being caught at their game.
This is in my top handful of most enjoyed audio books.
The beginning of this book was so dark and violent that I nearly gave up on it, but at the urging of other reviewers I kept going and am glad I did. The history of the exportation of persons judged to be criminals in London and banished to settle Australia came to life as Courtenay wove his tale, and the book culminates as a wonderful story of determination and survival.
During the tale, I was a little put off by what I thought was unnecessary antisemitism, but in his preface Courtenay had addressed that as factual so I looked upon it as a fact of life as it was at the time.
The narrator does an admirable job of using accents and a heavy brogue but speaks too quickly at times. At other times, the audio sounds as though it was artificially engineered to speed the narration, which also challenged comprehension. Nevertheless, the narration added greatly to the effectiveness of the story, and overall the book was a great listen.