I thought the reading was flawless, thoroughly enjoyed it. I thought the story left room for waffling.. as if the next book is going to begin on a clue which exonerates the character the crime is pinned on, depending on the public's outcry over the choice of the guilty party.
I was not happy with the ending, but I do love the reader.
I have listened to many great books but have never written a review. This book left me feeling completely satisfied. Can not wait to get another by this wonderful writer.
Louise Penney has written another of her beautifully worded stories - I've loved them all - but for those of you who want even more twists and turns this is it! All of your favorite characters, with an ending that is truly a surprise.
This is the fifth Inspector Gamache book I have read. One thing I like about this series is that we readers get to see the imperfect side of the characters in addition to all of things they do right. However, I didn't expect that behind the facade of one of the seemingly "normal" and likable Three Pines characters that we would ever find something like what is unveiled in this story!
I gave the story three stars -- I liked it, but just not as much as I've liked other Gamache books. I tend to like mysteries that have more to do with action, limiting the time spent on motive to a basic explanation -- and I felt that this book spent more time than I would have liked "inside the heads" of the victim and the perpetrator of the crime. Also, too much symbolism left unexplained throughout the story whose ultimate reason for being was weak.
The narrator is great.
Did not enjoy this book. I've read the series in chronological order up to this point, and have become increasingly disappointed with the lack of character development in these stories.
I am an avid "reader"- I prefer to listen to books rather than read them due to the added dimension added by the narrator.
I absolutely love these stories and the characters in them. Louise Penny is brilliant.
But Ralph Cosham makes these books come alive. Bravo! Going back to book one and going in order.
An avid reader, demanding of the story, characters and narrator. Mysteries and historical fiction are my favorites.
It is hard to write this review without spoiling the story, so I'll be intentionally vague. The characters are just as fully drawn and the story feels right; I still love them all and wish I lived there. What makes this bittersweet is that the plot is upsetting. STILL a great book and part of a series I couldn't recommend more highly. READ THIS!
You must go in order with the Three Pines series. And it helps if tu parles francais un peu.
I love books!
I was able to start reading Louise Penny novels with book #1 and I've methodically worked through them, this being book #6. Often when you read most or all of the works of a writer you can sense them evolving and their books get better the more they write. This book was #6 in the Chief Inspector Gamache crimve novels set in Three Pines, a fictituous, small village an hour south of Montreal, Quebec, Canada. Ms Penny has great character development and has created a great cast of characters that inhabit Three Pines and her novels are set around these characters plus new ones she introduces each book. This book was philosophic as Gamache unravles the murder he's trying to solve. Thoreau, pricelss old art, current Canadian art, Canadian history are all weaved into the story. I thoughly enjoyed this book and look forward to #7.
I don't usually rush out for all the "best sellers", but give each intriguing book/author a look. I have found many diamonds in the rough.
Appropriate Louise Penny, Three Pines, read for October, this being the darkest of the series for me thus far. We find our group of regulars each battling some of their own inner demons, while at the same time, trying to come to grips with the arrival of some much, unwanted outsiders. Even the landscapes in this addition were depicted more remote and shadowy than usual.
Inspector Gamache finds himself back in Three Pines, again-surrounded, by his friends and a mystery. There has been a death of a homeless man, who's body possesses some very strange physical attributes, that have Gamache, his team and the coroner at a loss. This investigation takes us deeper into the surprising backgrounds of several, Three Pines, residents who have been hiding some dark secrets for many years.
A wonderful mystery with the perfect amount of humor and beautiful snippets of philosophy woven throughout. Gamache would not be the same without Ralph Cosham's narration. Looking forward to the next in the series.
I enjoyed this book! 1/2 of the outcome I didn't care for (the identity of the bad guy) and 1/2 was perfect (Clara's success in spite of Peter.) The narration is great. Louise Penny creates more details of Three Pines adding and removing characters. Ms Penny does a fantastic job with all types of descriptions and has the imagination to keep Three Pines and its residents interesting. This series just keeps getting better!